John Key.
The Government is looking at removing protection for some
areas of conservation land so they can be mined, Prime Minister
John Key said today.
Energy Minister Gerry Brownlee last year controversially
started a stocktake of valuable minerals in conservation land
protected under Schedule Four of the Crown Minerals Act.
The estimated value of untapped minerals has been put at
about $140 billion - about 70 percent of that in the
conservation estate.
In his opening statement to Parliament today, Mr Key said
that a discussion paper on potential changes to land covered
under the schedule would recommend that some land be removed
and that other areas be added.
"Notwithstanding the public consultation process, it is my
expectation that the Government will act on at least some of
these recommendations and make significant changes to
Schedule 4," Mr Key said.
"This is because new mining on Crown land has the potential
to increase economic growth and create jobs." He said mining
on conservation land would have to meet strict environmental
tests.
"There is ... extraordinary economic potential in the mineral
estate residing in Crown-owned land." As a sweetener Mr Key
also announced a new Conservation Fund which could get some
of its revenue from mining operations on Crown land.
The fund would resource conservation projects.
Green Party co-leader Metiria Turei said that the decision
was terrible for New Zealand.
"He's going to try sell off the conservation land to
international mining interests and expect that the country
will be satisfied with a small conservation fund," she said.
"He's going to cause enormous damage to our tourism industry,
he's going to radically affect our biodiversity values in
this country which are already at serious risk, and for very
little value. Because most of our economic value in the
conservation estate is in its natural resources, its forests,
its clean waters not in the mineral wealth."
Mr Key said New Zealand needed to use its resources.
"At the moment less than one one-hundreth of one percent is
currently being mined. We think there is much greater
capability and capacity than that," he told reporters.
At the weekend Reserve Bank Governor Alan Bollard said the
Government's goal of catching up with Australia's growth and
wage rates was unrealistic and it should focus more on how it
could benefit from its bigger neighbour's wealth.
Mr Key today said Dr Bollard had highlighted the importance
of minerals to Australia's economy.
"Well, Alan Bollard might be satisfied with the crumbs off
Australia's table, I want the entre, the main course and the
dessert." Mr Brownlee would not say how much land would be
taken off the schedule.
"We have indicated what we think the gross potential value of
minerals in New Zealand is. Their recovered value to the
economy is another thing, we will just progress that slowly,"
he told reporters.
"We do think though it is a significant opportunity for the
country and we have been very cautious it will take some
years to develop. Conservation values are very important to
all New Zealanders and that is why we are going through the
exercise of having public consultation over anything we might
do with schedule four."
Environmental lobby group EDS (Environmental Defence Society)
responded cautiously to the announcement.
"We have still to see exactly what the government proposes
when it releases a discussion paper on mining later this
month or early next," says EDS Chairman Gary Taylor.
"Our expectation is that government will call for public
comment on its proposed changes to Schedule 4 of the Crown
Minerals Act. So this is presumably not a done deal, but one
in which minds are still open to public feedback.
"EDS does not oppose mining on all Crown owned conservation
land. It's a question of limiting mining to lower value areas
for nature conservation and continuing to protect higher
value areas. So let's see the detail of what is proposed and
assess at that time whether it's reasonable or not."
Mr Taylor noted Mr Key had said some areas of conservation
land not currently protected by Schedule 4 might be afforded
that protection, and he said that demonstrated the
review was not just "one-way traffic".
Mr Key had also announced a proposed Conservation Fund from
royalties on Crown minerals.
"Provided it is new, additional money for conservation, and
not a replacement for cut baseline funding, it is a good
idea. But it must be designed in such a way that it doesn't
create perverse incentives for decision-makers to lower
environmental standards," Mr Taylor said.
"Finally, if more Crown land is to be opened up to mining we
will be relying on the Resource Management Act to ensure that
it's undertaken in an environmentally acceptable way. So
further weakening of the RMA should not be contemplated."
A name, residential address, and (preferably residential) telephone number is required from readers who comment on ODT Online. These details will not be visible to site visitors.