Classical reviews

This week Classical reviewer Geoff Adams listens to a recording of Puccini's Madame Butterfly featuring Angela Gheorghiu and Jonas Kauffman, and violin concertos by Louis Spohr.

> Giacomo Puccini: Madame Butterfly. Angela Gheorghiu, Jonas Kauffman, etc. EMI 2CDs.

Bouquets for this studio recording of the full-length opera: to its soloists, chorus and orchestra (from the Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia, conducted by Antonio Pappano.) It is a lively performance all round, immaculately recorded.

For many, Gheorghiu must replace classic recordings by Callas and Scotto as a preferred modern soprano Butterfly.

She endows the geisha role with great colour and vocal texture; tenor Kauffman's husky Pinkerton is also excellent.

The packaging of this set is a two-CD "Limited Edition" deluxe clamshell, with 152-page booklet, libretto (and translations), synopsis, liner notes and photos.

Beautifully presented and made in the 150th anniversary of Puccini's birth, EMI has done him honour. This is a future classic.

Highlights: Gheorghiu outstanding in In bel di vedremo and Butterfly's death scene.


> Louis Spohr: Violin Concertos 6, 8 and 11. Simone Lamsma, Sinfonia Finlandia Jyvaskyla. Naxos CD.

Spohr (1784-1859) was a famous German violinist in his time and he trained more than 200 violinists, composers and conductors. He wrote many operas, nine symphonies, and much chamber music.

His 18 violin concertos are delightful - lyrical and elegant, including elements of Paganini's virtuosity.

They should be played less rarely in concerts; Lamsma, a young Dutch soloist who has won many honours, displays the outstanding beauty of three of them on this fine recording.

The works include many formidable passages - double stopping and slurred staccatos played with ease.

Lamsma has a fast vibrato in the style of Maurice Hasson, one of her mentors. Patrick Gallois conducts a sensitive orchestral accompaniment.

Highlight: Gorgeous tone of 1709 Carlo Tononi violin captured by the engineers.

 

 

Your review of Madama Butterfly misses the mark re AG

AG is among the most "glamorous" of singers, but certainly not among the best. Clearly the reviewer has not heard -major league - sopranos sing this same role, esp. Renee F or Cece D - whose league is far above the one Ms Burlacu-Georghiu sings in.

JK however, is a different matter - he is AG's protege. They are in fact an item, for what its worth - and he is in the top flight of tenors. The recording is a recording, and does not represent how Ms AG sounds in a real performance, by a country mile nor, as you should know, in her nearly two-decade career - has AG performed this role onstage - for reasons you should also know very well.