Stadium truss schedule set back

Work to fit giant steel roof trusses to the Forsyth Barr Stadium is months behind schedule, but Carisbrook Stadium Trust (CST) chairman Malcolm Farry insists the setback is not critical.

Mr Farry yesterday confirmed the first of five arch trusses - part of the roof steelwork linking the north and south stands - was not expected to be hoisted into position until next week.

That would make the lift nearly three months behind schedule, when compared with a stadium construction programme presented to the Dunedin City Council by CST staff last October.

That programme had the first arch scheduled for placement above the stadium's playing pitch area by May 7, followed by two more arches by May 25 and July 1.

To keep to that October timetable, three of the five arches should have been in position by yesterday, with 50% of the playing area cleared.

Mr Farry said the first of the arches was now expected to be in place next week, but the exact date was "not yet confirmed".

"The contractors have got to have everything perfect on the ground before they start the lift."

The first of three Rugby World Cup 2011 matches scheduled for Dunedin - Scotland v Georgia - will be played on September 14.

If the Forsyth Barr Stadium is not completed in time, those matches will be staged at Carisbrook.

Mr Farry said the timing of individual construction components could, and did, shift, without threatening the completion date, August 1 next year.

Delays could be offset by quicker progress in other areas, but the key was to hit major milestones along the construction critical path.

For the roof, that meant having the completed structure in place by November or December, to allow grass for the turf to be sown, he said.

"The stages to reach that milestone are less critical.

"Even if you miss the [roof] deadline for the end of the year, it still doesn't mean we are not going to make completion date.

"It just means ... they probably have to put something aside for a period of time and just put every focus on the roof," Mr Farry said.

Asked if multiple missed deadlines would have a concertina effect, adding more pressure to later deadlines, Mr Farry acknowledged it "would eventually".

"But there's no indication of that," he said.

A progress report to be presented to Monday's finance and strategy committee meeting said the project remained on time and within budget, and Mr Farry said yesterday he remained "100%" confident the venue would be ready.

 

More Questions Please

Great to see the ODT pick up on my Letter to the Editor with their front page story on the stadium timetable on Saturday. Although they didn’t publish the letter, they did confirm my belief that the project was at least three months behind schedule.

I did pose two other questions which they didn’t answer. Why do the Stakeholder reports to DCC not longer show a progress chart? The last time the Stakeholder Progress Report showed such a chart was in October 2009 and looking at that report I struggle to see how Mr Farry can catch up three months backlog in the 12 months remaining.

Although 29 July was a Milestone by when three trusses and half the roof should have been installed, recent reports just say everything is on track and on budget when that clearly is not the case.

The ODT also did not get an answer the most important questions I raised – Who is paying for the extra work which will be needed to meet Mr Farry's new schedule. And can the DCC absolutely assure us that we will not have to pay one cent more that the $198.3m already committed?

This lack of transparency is just one of the reasons I’m standing for Council this year.

Lindsay Smith
Challis Point

Obfuscation the name of the game

The reason for the delay and why it is not stated? Answer:1. If you say too much people will ask more questions. 2. They don't want to admit before the election that the stadium won't meet RWC deadline.

What's the problem in admitting that?  Key has now said he doesn't want to be an Indian-giver where we have to hand back the conditional $15m Government gift for the stadium. OK, there's a bit of lost pride, but it has always been on the cards that the stadium won't be ready.

The critical path

Do the councillors actually have a copy of the critical path for stadium construction, to see for themselves, or are they just briefed on progress by Malcolm Farry?

It seems hard to believe the continued assertions that the stadium is 'on time and on budget' with the example of the delay in erecting the roof trusses - something I would have thought is major and affects other aspects of the stadium construction timetable.

On time and within budget

Give or take many millions of dollars and several months, this statement is perfectly accurate. Keep up the good work, CST.

Stadium roof truss delay

It was no surprise to me that the marketing for the Wales vs NZ Test earlier this year was "The Last All Black Test", rather than "the last test" at Carisbrook. Perhaps there could be another couple of tests played there next year?

Time will tell, but I don't expect it to be disposed of for some time yet so there goes another wad of ratepayers funds to keep it running for a year. It has to stay as a contingency for the stadium not being ready. Always part of the plan, I guess.

In terms of the schedule for the new stadium, it depends on where the roof installation is on the critical path for the project and if other tasks can be done in paralell to the roof work.
Alternatively, the contractor will have to throw more resources at the roof - but that means more cost. Not good for them on fixed price.

One thing I don't get from Mr Farry's comment is that everything needs to be right on the ground for the lift. True, but three trusses have not been completed yet (from what I can see), regardless of what is ready on the ground.
Does that mean that the trusses are behind schedule? And the things on the ground?

Stadium steelwork delay

The reason for the delay is not stated. Why not?

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Kitz Homewares WanakaWanakaHomeware
CARTERS DunedinDunedinBuilding Supplies
Back In Motion Physiotherapy Clinic, South Dunedin DunedinPhysiotherapists
Washing Machine Repair Service (Dunedin) LtdDunedinAppliances