Hope to recoup 'Brook $7m

Prime real estate - Carisbrook. Photo by Gerard O'Brien.
Prime real estate - Carisbrook. Photo by Gerard O'Brien.
Initial responses from real estate companies vying for the job of selling the historic Carisbrook ground suggest the $7 million paid for the land by the Dunedin City Council might be recouped.

Prices of between $200 and $300 per square metre are suggested in the real estate proposals which would result in a return of between $6 million and $9 million, says the DCC.

With the marketing campaign soon to begin, the illustrious history of the 130-year-old-plus ground is expected to be an important aspect of its appeal to potential buyers.

Other possible attractions are the nearby rail siding, multiple street frontages and the infrastructure already in place.

Six of eight residential properties across the road from Carisbrook, in Burns St, have already been sold, DCC property manager Robert Clark said last night.

A decision on which company would sell the land was expected in two or three weeks, and the marketing campaign should begin soon after that.

The final decision, though, would go before the council's political arm for approval.

In January, the council voted to sell the property, including the car park next door, as industrial land, subject to final consultation during the annual plan. The council ratified that decision in May.

Public consultation was held last year and some people wanted to keep the facility as a sports ground. The council was aware it would incur holding costs of about $440,000 each year once the Otago Rugby Football Union moved out.

Mr Clark has said he expected willing buyers for the site, with industrial freehold land at a premium in Dunedin.

There were eight marketing proposals from real estate firms, which included methods of sale, pricing and potential buyers, and other aspects of the sale such as a dedicated website. All had suggested sale by tender.

The companies were local, national and international companies, some with partnerships encompassing all three.

Mr Clark said he hoped to complete a report for the DCC's executive management team by this week on which company to use.

A report on the grandstand demolition requirements at the site showed there would be a "substantial amount" of recyclables.

Most of the proposals from the real estate companies, though, had suggested retaining the newer building on the terrace that housed corporate boxes.

The firms had also pointed to the New Zealand Historic Places Trust (NZHPT) category one protection for the playing field and the single-storey turnstile building below the Neville St Stand.

Accept them all

Accept all the real estate company offers to try and sell the land. Make the offers public, let potential buyers shop around and see which realtor is going to charge the least (and therefore end up with the city getting most money, and being more likely to accept their offer). The city can reserve the right to accept a smaller offer through a realtor charging a smaller commission that results in the city getting a larger return.

The city should also accept offers directly from the public without a realtor taking a cut. We paid $7m for Carisbrook but the ORFU only received $6m - there's no reason why we should make that mistake again.

There's no reason for "commercial sensitivity" when choosing a realtor. In the past secrecy in such dealings has resulted in people paying far too much for the land underneath stadiums and the like.

Make some money

I hope the council can make some money out of this by selling off "collectables". There are a lot of things at the ground that people would buy.

For example, I'd buy a row of seats to have in the garden. There's the turf - imagine having that laid in your backyard. Goal posts - The Eden Park goal poats were sold for $15,000 recently. Scoreboard - would look good in a bar somewhere. Signage - Imagine having that at a home bar or office. The roof off the main stand - this was done at Lancaster Park where it was cut into small sections and sold to collectors. A square of concrete from the terrace. Imagine having a turnstile in the garden. Parts of the changing room benches could be sold off. There are plenty of good money making oppurtunities to recover some of the costs of the new stadium. I'm sure at least a million could be raised.

Hopefully the DCC will sell it all of and make some money rather than the company that buys the 'brook.

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Mosgiel Stationery & Art SuppliesMosgielBooks & Stationery
Two Paddocks LtdAlexandraWineries
Willowbrook OrchardRoxburghOrchards
Jacks Mitre 10MosgielGardening