Recycling bins to be checked for rubbish

A soiled nappy found in recycling. Photo by Craig Baxter.
A soiled nappy found in recycling. Photo by Craig Baxter.
The Dunedin City Council is planning more door-to-door checks aimed at lifting the lid on the contents of the city's wheelie bins, as part of a crackdown on recycling contamination.

Council solid waste manager Ian Featherston yesterday said extra checks were planned that would see council staff or contractors scrutinising recycling wheelie bins on streets for improper use.

He also warned the council would need to consider raising the $63-per-household cost of the scheme, paid through rates bills, if contamination levels continued to soar.

The $63 cost was based in part on an expected contamination level of 5%, he said.

However, it was confirmed last week a steady stream of used nappies, needles and other non-recyclable items - even including a pig's head - had driven contamination levels up to about 12%.

"It's much higher than we had initially anticipated," Mr Featherston said.

"If the contamination rates keep staying up this high, we'll have to be putting up the cost of the service.

"We can't expect the contractors and the service to be suffering through people just using it for rubbish."

His comments came after the ODT last week reported workers at the Green Island recycling plant were weeding out high volumes of non-recyclables discarded in the ratepayer-funded wheelie bins.

One worker was also awaiting blood test results, after being stabbed by one of many needles and syringes arriving with the city's recycling.

Mr Featherston yesterday described the behaviour of some residents misusing the wheelie bins as "amazing".

"It's just laziness by some residents, and it's just contaminating and mucking up the system."

Plans for extra wheelie bin inspections were being discussed with contractors, and would likely result in more warning cards being issued and wheelie bins confiscated, he confirmed.

"We're going to be looking at more of the bins ... so that we get the contamination levels down and have the right materials in the bins."

He would not say when the checks were likely to begin, for fear of tipping off offenders.

Other New Zealand centres operating similar collectionsystems had contamination levels around 5%, and Dunedin's higher level could be put down in part to people "trying to test the system", Mr Featherston believed.

Staff at the Green Island plant were being "more stringent", meaning a cleaner stream of recyclables available for sale at the end of the process, but also higher volumes of contamination collected.

The appearance of needles and syringes was an industry-wide problem, but contractors in Dunedin were discussing ways of better protecting their staff, he said.

"If people just took the conscientious step of only recycling what we've got [listed on wheelie bins], and putting the rest in rubbish bags, we'd be OK."

chris.morris@odt.co.nz

Have you considered this?

When I look up and down our street on collection day, it invariably contains cars parked up against (and frequently on) the footpaths. Many of these are owned by multiple-car families who park one car in the drive and spread the remainder around the neighbourhood; a 'right' many of them would vigorously defend. Consequently, a major problem with the collection of most bins from in front of our residence, is to have them seen by the collectors in the first place.

The solution lies with the council doing something about those who aggressively park on the 'long-acre' and making them park on their own patch, instead of on the street to the detriment of other residents.

In my experience, the 'Rozzers' are quite happy to dish out tickets for minor infractions which cause a fraction of the inconvenience this practice does. My attitude is simple: park in front of our place if you are left with no alternative, (I am aware that may sometimes be necessary), but fill the space in front of your own (place), first. Maybe then, we could put our bin(s) out, with some kind of assurance that they will be collected.  [Abridged]

Execution

I assume from your comments Pukeko that you haven't seen these types of trucks in action - the arm is generally all automatic and pick the bins up from the footpath.

I am not against the fine system but we need to be careful in terms of finding a way to do it.   I would also be interested in what the increase in cost on the rates is - it might only be $1. 

Re: Issues with execution

It would only need to happen on two or three weeks… and would be a cheaper option than stinging every ratepayer week after week, in particular those who use the recycling correctly.

The bins may well be picked up by the arm with driver nowhere near, but someone has to place the bins on the arm - the guys at the back. 
I’m sure a glimpse in there would pick up the offenders, with non-recyclables mostly spotted.

Issues with execution

Where are the funds going to come from to cover the extra people (person) on the runs? By lifting the overall cost, as they will not be covered by fines, especially if it works as a deterrent as intended.   They also don't "tip it into the truck" by hand. They are picked up by the arm on the truck and tipped into the top of the truck with the driver nowhere near it.

Re: execution

Good point… a rough idea?  I’d imagine the collector guys get a good idea of the regular offenders and take a note, perhaps having another person doing this on a run or two, ‘lifting the lid’ on this situation, or following their nose.  A rather vile-smelling bin and a mere glimpse as they went to tip it into the truck would sight and smell the non recylables without needing to go through it. 

Execution

Great idea pukeko - how exactly are they going to be able to do it without going through the recycling bins on the side of the road?

Deal to the culprits, not all of us!

I can fully understand the frustration with morons who cannot follow the easy guidelines  and throw all manner of things in there, but why penalise all those who do recycle correctly?  I take care to wash all items before placing in bin.  Aside from anything else, it keeps bad smells and flies away.

 

Only those who don’t recycle correctly should be directly hit in the pocket for their folly, not the rest of us.

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
University Book Shop Otago LtdDunedinBooks & Stationery
Proactive Health & Fitness CentreWanaka
Smiths City LtdOamaruHomeware
Qbook - Queenstown Booking & InfoQueenstownInformation Centres