Physio pool users Barbara Bucke (left) and Angela Melrose
aqua-jogging in the physio pool this week. Photo by Linda
The swims that transformed paraplegic Jim Duncan's life
after a devastating cycling crash will end if the physio pool
closes in December.
Mr Duncan (66) has no memory of his bike leaving Highcliff Rd
in February 2012. The crash left him paralysed from the
After nearly five months in hospital in Christchurch, the
once fit and active Mr Duncan returned home a ''shell of his
former self'', wife Sue Duncan says.
With the help of physiotherapist Mark Shirley, over 18 months
he worked up to 40 lengths of the pool freestyle.
The swimming built his fitness to a level where he takes part
in fun run events in his wheelchair. He can also go cycling
in a special hand-bike, and enjoys weekend rides with his
''I never would have been able to do that type of exercise
aerobically without the benefit of my swimming.
''I can't say enough, really. Aerobically it helps in
everything I do, every day,'' Mr Duncan said.
It took a long time to get his flotation set-up right, which
was ''definitely'' only possible at the physio pool. Moana
Pool is not suited to Mr Duncan's needs, partly because he is
prone to hypothermia.
In contrast, the physio pool warms his body right through,
especially useful in the chilly Dunedin winter.
Closing the pool would be unfair and short-sighted, he said.
''It's going to be used more and more with the population
The cash-strapped Southern District Health Board plans to
close the pool in December.
It is now up to city leaders and pool users to find a way to
save the therapeutic and historic facility.
For Dunedin woman Barbara Bucke (68), the pool alleviated
back problems caused by her many years as a nurse.
She has swum in the pool for two decades, her nursing career
having pre-dated modern lifting equipment. Everybody was
accepted at the pool: ''It's a place where everybody's
Physiotherapy student Jess Chicksen assists paraplegic Jim
Duncan, who was swimming with his wife Sue Duncan. Another
physio client, Judy Oats, is on the right. Photo by Gregor
Because of the pool she had more flexibility, less pain,
and virtually ''lived'' in the water after disc removal surgery
several years ago.
''I was told not to go to Moana Pool. It was too cold, and I
would seize up.''
Equally passionate about the pool is Mrs Bucke's friend
Judith Reader, who has swum there off and on since 1969.
The 61-year-old shut her thumb in the hatchback of a car in
A subsequent surgical procedure seriously damaged a nerve
affecting the hand and arm. The arm could seize up if it was
not kept moving.
''[The pool's] kept my arm mobile to the extent that it is.
''What I think of [the closure] you wouldn't print.
''The Moana Pool is no good to me because the water's too
cold,'' Ms Reader said.
The city loses more than a rehabilitation and health facility
if the pool closes, as the Mason and Wales designed building
is part of Dunedin's architectural and medical heritage.
That it is still used for its original therapeutic purpose
keeps alive the shift the pool represents towards
exercise-based therapy in the middle of the last century.
Architectural historian Michael Findlay, a professional
practice fellow at the University of Otago, says in keeping
with its purpose the pool has a plain exterior, but a rather
beautiful and elegant interior.
The designers saved something special for the inside, an
exposed concrete truss carrying the weight of the roof that
spans the structure in a single sweep.
''The pool doesn't look anything particularly flash from the
outside, because it was never intended to. It was a utility
Built in 1946, the Otago Therapeutic Pool has a category two
listing with Heritage New Zealand (formerly the New Zealand
Historic Places Trust).
He is following the debate over the pool's future closely,
and has some sympathy with the board's financial plight.
If it could not be kept open as a pool, the building's
heritage values could be retained if it was converted to
another purpose, Mr Findlay said.