Sending an intellectually impaired convicted murderer to
prison was inhumane, and he should serve the remainder of his
sentence in a care facility, a court was told today.
Jason Mark Ferguson, 30, is appealing his sentence at the
Court of Appeal in Wellington.
He was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum
non-parole period of 10 years when he was found guilty of
murdering caregiver John Sorrenson near Rotorua in June 2002.
He admitted hitting and stabbing Mr Sorrenson several times.
The men met while hitch-hiking and spent an evening together.
Ferguson alleged Mr Sorrenson had grabbed at his penis when
he came out of the shower.
After murdering Mr Sorrenson in his Mamaku home, north west
of Rotorua, Ferguson buried him in a shallow grave in a
forest south of Putaruru.
During his trial he said the incident brought back a past
memory of sexual abuse, and caused him to lose control.
Ferguson's appeals of his conviction, based on the argument
he was not mentally fit to stand trial, reached the Supreme
Court, however, all appeals failed.
Today, human rights lawyer Tony Ellis told Justices Terence
Arnold, Lynton Stevens and Christine French, Ferguson should
have been sentenced to a care facility, not prison.
When the crime was committed and the trial and sentencing
took place, Ferguson was 19-years-old with an IQ of only 57
and very few convictions, Mr Ellis said.
"His intellectual state was not taken into account at the
time of sentence," he said.
"A humane sentence for someone with an intellectual
disability of this level would be locked up in secure care."
Mr Ellis said the public would still be safe from Fergusson
if he was moved to a care facility, and he would have the
benefit of effective treatment at the facility.
"The man's already done 10 years in prison, and now can he
have some movement so one day he could have a life outside of
Annabel Markham, appearing for the Crown, said Ferguson has
been wait-listed for a treatment programme next year, and the
Corrections Department could allow him to start the course if
he was willing to participate.
"So it's not the case that Corrections has done nothing," she
There had been numerous rehabilitative efforts made towards
Ferguson, but he had been resistant to those programmes, Ms
The order to have people serve their time in a care facility
was reserved for more minor offending, she said.
"The care order in lieu of a sentence is an unrealistic
option in this case."
Ferguson failed in a parole bid this year, and would next be
eligible in May 2013.
The Justices reserved their decision.