A world expert on women and crime says a "moral panic" about
violent girls is seeing more of them arrested and jailed,
even though evidence suggests they are actually becoming less
Meda Chesney-Lind, a Hawaiian women's studies professor who
is in Auckland for a criminology conference, said the panic
was fuelled by media firms appealing to chauvinist men by
portraying women - especially black women - as violent.
The story was reinforced by "zero tolerance" policing
policies which led to more females being arrested for minor
crimes that would once have been dismissed with a warning.
"I looked at juvenile robbery because it seemed to be hugely
increasing," she said. "It turned out the average amount
being stolen was $2.50."
As a result, girls had increased from 21 per cent of juvenile
arrests in 1983 to 30 per cent last year in the United
States, and from 19 per cent in 2001 to 22 per cent in 2010
in New Zealand.
Yet US surveys showed that both girls and boys were actually
becoming much less violent. Only 23 per cent of girls and 39
per cent of boys had been in a fight in the past year in
2009, compared with 34 per cent of girls and 50 per cent of
boys in 1991.
New Zealand surveys of secondary school students by the
University of Auckland's Youth 2000 unit also found slight
reductions in fighting between their two surveys published so
far in 2001 and 2007.
Only 12.2 per cent of girls and 26.2 per cent of boys had
been in a serious physical fight in the past year in their
2007 survey, compared with 14.5 per cent of girls and 27.9
per cent of boys in 2001.
"This 'crime wave' doesn't exist," Professor Chesney-Lind
But news media played up girls' violence in a "backlash"
against feminism which appealed to men, choosing images of
young women holding guns or in other violent poses.
"There is nothing accidental about any of these media images.
Girls peering over the barrel of a gun is just hugely
popular," she said.
Most of the photos were of black women. A study of how female
drug offenders were depicted in 17 newspapers found that
white women were typically shown at home with their families
talking about how they had reformed, whereas black and Latino
women were portrayed as "there she goes again, we let her
out, she's back on drugs".
"But even false moral panics have real consequences,"
Professor Chesney-Lind said. "Between 1991 and 2003
detentions of girls went up 98 per cent, while detentions of
boys went up only 29 per cent.
"African-American girls represent nearly half of those in
detention. Seven out of 10 cases involving white girls were
dismissed, compared with three out of 10 cases involving
Women have also increased as a proportion of New Zealand
prisoners, though more modestly - from 5.1 per cent in 2001
to 6.1 per cent in June.
Nelson anthropologist Donna Swift agreed that there was not
enough evidence to say whether girls' violence was actually
increasing. But she said there was a lack of gender-specific
programmes to address it.
"We can't really say that it's growing," she said. "We can
say that what we have got, we are not addressing in a good
- By Simon Collins of the New Zealand Herald