Police have been cleared over the shooting of a man who
barricaded himself in a wardrobe with a loaded rifle during a
tense stand-off last year.
Kapiti man William Robert Hartley, 29, was shot twice through
the wardrobe door after pointing the rifle at one of three
officers who raided his house in Otaki on February 24.
Hartley suffered two non life-threatening wounds to his right
hand and forearm before being taken into custody.
He was sentenced in August to four years in prison after a
jury found him guilty of two charges of using a firearm
against a member of police.
An Independent Police Conduct Authority (IPCA) investigation
has found police were justified in shooting Hartley during
The authority's report, released today, said police were
first warned Hartley had possession of a firearm when a woman
reported being assaulted and left at the side of the road at
Levin on February 14, Valentine's Day last year.
The woman told a police central communications staff member
that Hartley had threatened to shoot her and had access to
firearms, although she had not seen them herself.
Police placed Hartley's home under observation and decided to
enter it on February 24. The officers were armed but were not
wearing ballistic body armour.
One occupant was arrested for obstructing police before the
officers entered the house, where Hartley had overturned
furniture to barricade himself in a bedroom.
He refused to come out despite repeated requests and a failed
attempt to force the door open.
One of the officers could see Hartley through a hole in the
door, standing in the middle of the room and apparently
When Hartley started to move as though intent on harming
himself, the officer forced the door open.
Hartley then partially hid in a wardrobe and took hold of a
rifle, which he pointed at one officer before training it on
The first officer immediately stepped out of the room and
drew his Glock pistol, while the other, who was two metres
from the barrel trained on him, also drew his Glock and fired
two rounds through the wardrobe door.
Hartley's rifle was found to be fully loaded with eight
rounds, including one in the breach which was cocked and
ready to fire at the pull of the trigger.
In his findings, IPCA chairman Judge Sir David Carruthers
said police had used sound judgment and complied with the law
in deciding to use potentially lethal force.
"The officer was justified in using force to defend himself
and the force was not excessive in the circumstances."
He found there was no opportunity for the officers to
consider other tactical options available to them.
There was no undue delay in the officers giving Hartley first
aid and seeking medical help after he was shot.
But the report was also critical of the officers and their
supervisor for failing to wear ballistic body armour while
The IPCA recommended all staff be reminded of their
obligation to wear armour while carrying firearms, in
accordance with police policy.
The IPCA was also critical that police did not update the
national intelligence application on February 14 to record
information about Hartley's alleged access to firearms.
The authority said it was satisfied that matter had been
dealt with appropriately by the police district.