Poll backs plan for better teachers

New Zealanders would rather money was spent on improving teaching standards than on reducing class sizes, a Herald-DigiPoll survey reveals.

Education has become a political battleground before September's election, with both major parties promising to spend hundreds of millions of dollars on it.

Asked about their priorities, more than 60 per cent of those polled said they would spend money on trying to improve teaching standards rather than cutting class sizes.

Labour has included reducing class sizes in its election policies.

Another of its policies, a promise to pay schools which do not ask parents for donations, gained support in the poll.

National has pledged $359 million for a scheme that would pay the best teachers and principals more.

Labour countered by promising to use that money to instead hire 2000 more teachers and reduce class sizes.

Asked about those policies, 61 per cent of those polled said the money was better spent on trying to improve teaching standards.

Thirty-five per cent thought it should be used to cut class sizes.

Yesterday, Labour education spokesman Chris Hipkins said he rejected the premise of the question.

It did not convey that Labour's plan to hire more teachers would also allow for teacher training, and that its education policy was strongly focused on teacher quality.

That included establishing an advisory service to provide mentors and share best practices, and pre-screening entry into teacher training programmes. "Smaller class sizes do lead to better teaching. The teacher gets more time with each student, student behaviour is improved, and studies clearly show that students in smaller classes spend more time focused on the task at hand.

"Smaller class sizes also allow the teacher more time to reflect on and improve their own practice."

Labour's class size policy followed other announcements, including paying schools which did not ask parents for donations and subsidised netbooks or laptops for students.

Education Minister Hekia Parata said the survey showed parents recognised the worth in the initiative.

"Parents have great knowledge about what makes a difference for their kids' learning, and it is about the quality of learning that happens in their child's classroom."

This month the Post Primary Teachers' Association conducted its own survey which showed that more than eight in 10 New Zealanders wanted secondary school classes at 25 or lower.

The union also supports National's Investing in Educational Success plan, in contrast to the strong opposition from the NZEI primary teachers' union.

The Herald-DigiPoll survey of 750 voters was taken between July 10-17.

- By Nicholas Jones of the New Zealand Herald


Isn't it a funny coincidence that almost everything the NZ Herald publishes is pro National, and anti every other party? [Abridged]

Devil take the hindmost

So you pay the best more and disenfranchise the others who really need help and incentive. Another great plan.

Both needed

Under most conditions, you cannot measurably improve teacher performance without reducing class sizes, at least beyond a certain threshold. I don't have the time to report the empirical stats on this, but it is a generally accepted axiom of education that smaller class sizes lead to better learning outcomes. Since the only way to measure the effectiveness of "improved teaching standards" is in the performance of the students so taught, it stands to reason that one must embrace both smaller class sizes and improved teaching standards (which I'd prefer to call better teacher training). Dragging parents into the mix to hold up their end of the bargain is also a must - we can hardly expect teachers to improve their performance if the students themselves aren't also invested in the process, and I suspect that parents might have some say in students' investment. There, that's all I wanted to say. Now somebody go and find all the money to make this magic happen...

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
BrickworxArrowtownSpecialist Trades
Queenstown Holiday RentalsQueenstownApartments
White Room Design StoreDunedinHome Furnishings
Hair Thou ArtHaweaHairdressers