Man jailed 17 years for pawn shop stabbings

A man who stabbed two men two death at a South Auckland pawn shop in a "senseless and unprovoked" attack will spend at least 17 years in jail.

Zarn Tarapata (26) was found guilty of the murders of Paul Fanning (69) and 47-year-old Paul Matthews after a May trial in the High Court at Auckland and was today sentenced to life imprisonment.

The jury rejected the defence that he was insane at the time of the killing and sided with the Crown, which argued that he was using methamphetamine, was delusional and acted out of anger and jealousy.

Justice Pamela Andrews said the tragedy caused by Tarapata was "plain and enormous".

"The loss and grief to both families is absolutely unimaginable," she said.

Tarapata's partner and mother of his three children Tamara Cassie worked at Ezy Cash with the victims and was at the premises on July 19 last year.

Minutes after dropping her off, the defendant walked through the store into the lunch room where he slit Mr Matthews' throat and stabbed him 15 times before stabbing Mr Fanning six times.

Both bled to death on the floor as Tarapata fled in the car with his partner and their children. He was found later that night near his family's home in Huntly.

"Part of the real tragedy is just how senseless and unprovoked these killings were," Crown prosecutor Josh Shaw said.

"Mr Matthews and Mr Fanning had done nothing to invite the attention or anger of Mr Tarapata. To the contrary, there is some information before the court that suggests they had always been generous to Ms Cassie and her family."

Tarapata had provided letters of remorse to families of the victims but Mr Shaw said they were reluctant to accept the "bitter pill".

Massive gap, sister tells court 

Mr Matthews' sister Julia Matiu said her brother was a "gentle giant" and the thought of him calling for help had been a huge burden on her.

"The fact he's no longer in the world has left a massive gap . . . a good guy taken way too soon," she said.

Ms Matiu and two other sisters also directed comments at Tarapata who sat in the dock with his head down throughout.

"I hope you can understand my pain and that of my family. Maybe you could've just asked for help instead of taking someone's life for the sake of your own," she said.

"I feel sorry for your children. So many lives have been destroyed by the acts of one man."

Mr Fanning's daughter Jenny Squire described her dad as "a bit gruff" but always generous when someone needed help.

"I live with the trauma of what happened. The images and information I can never un-hear and never un-see," she told the court.

Tarapata's lawyer Bruce Hesketh said his client was psychotic at the time and his mental health should be at the forefront of the court's considerations.

The defendant, who was diagnosed with schizophrenia, could still not fully comprehend what had happened, he said.

Despite allowing the photographs of Tarapata to be taken at sentencing, Justice Andrews reversed her decision at the last minute this morning.

She reduced his sentence for his mental health issues and "sincere remorse" and imposed a minimum period of imprisonment of 17 years, before he will be eligible for parole.

 

Add a Comment

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter