Shearer backed as Labour leader

David Shearer speaks to media at today's caucus meeting in Henderson. Photo / Brett Phibbs
David Shearer speaks to media at today's caucus meeting in Henderson. Photo / Brett Phibbs
Labour's MPs have endorsed the leadership of David Shearer in a confidence vote today but will not release the results of the vote.

Under new party rules, the leader must get at least 60 per cent of support from caucus or it triggers a contest on which the party's membership and affiliates can vote.

The vote, held at a meeting in Auckland this morning, took about half an hour and Mr Shearer was applauded before emerging to announce the results - saying he was safe until the election in 2014.

He said he did not know the exact result because it was a secret ballot - but he had achieved the 60 per cent threshold required - at least 22 of the MPs.

Mr Shearer will travel to Waitangi tomorrow before turning his attention back to his reshuffle, planned for early this year.

That has been on hold partly while Mr Shearer waits for an Auditor-General's report into Shane Jones' decision when he was a government minister to grant citizenship to Bill Liu.

The confidence vote was part of a full-day caucus meeting at an old church at Corbans Estate in Henderson.

On his way into the caucus, David Cunliffe said it was a secret ballot so he would not discuss how he would vote. Last month he said he would endorse Mr Shearer.

Mr Shearer outflanked Mr Cunliffe in an effective challenge at the party conference last year.

Many other MPs going in also refused to say how they would vote, saying it was a secret ballot.

They included Cunliffe allies Nanaia Mahuta, Louisa Wall, and Charles Chauvel.

However, Moana Mackey, regarded as a supporter of Mr Cunliffe, said she will endorse Mr Shearer.

Other MPs also openly said they would vote for Mr Shearer including Phil Goff, Chris Hipkins and David Clark as well as Mr Jones, who said he hoped the venue of an old church would provide some "divine inspiration."

After this year, the new rules will require the confidence vote to be held soon after each election, rather than in the year preceding an election.

 

Conspiracy desperation

Te Jackle appears unfamiliar with the procedure of the secret ballot since he asks "So do we take him [David Shearer] at his word or has he failed to reach the 60% threshold but is hiding it behind the "secret ballot" smoke and mirrors."  Unless the Labour protocol is bizarrely different from the norm, Mr Shearer did not personally collect voting papers from each voter, hide them in his briefcase then sneak away to a nearby toilet so that if there were not enough in his favour he could flush the inconvenient ones away. The internet is a wonderful resource.  One could search "secret ballot" and become well-informed or one could choose to indulge in speculation that is insulting to Mr Shearer and to the intelligence of ODT online readers.

No hope for Labour

It won't matter who is the leader of the Labour party. They will still struggle to get in at the next election. The voters have had enough of Labour after their last nine year stint under auntie Helen. John Key and National blatantly stated they were going to sell assets, if re-elected and they still got in. The voters have realised that rather than turning NZ into a nanny state, they prefer the debts to be paid. DCC take note.

How do we know?

So what were the results of the so called secret ballot, according to Mr Shearer:

He said he did not know the exact result because it was a secret ballot - but he had achieved the 60 per cent threshold required - at least 22 of the MPs. 

So do we take him at his word or has he failed to reach the 60% threshold but is hiding it behind the "secret ballot" smoke and mirrors.

Release the results so we know them as well.

Not Goff and not off

Not strong? The Opposition Leader has negotiated in a Middle East war zone. Not your usual PSA around the table, those fellas carrying AKs.

Worse than Goff

Labour needed to roll him and put someone strong in who has the ability to win the confidence of swing voters. Shearer is a nice guy, and nice guys finish last so I can't vote for that. John Key will destroy him in a debate. A PM should be able to get his message across clearly. Cunliffe was too far in the other direction - far too smug! Smug is not what the anti-John Key voters want. Labour must have someone with a better chance?

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Nigel Wilson Art GalleryAlexandraArt Galleries & Museums
Peregrine WinesQueenstownWineries
The Bay CafeDunedinCafés
Clinton AutomotiveClintonServicing & Mechanics