'Range of villains' in Novopay fiasco - Joyce

Steven Joyce.
Steven Joyce.
Novopay Minister Steven Joyce says there is "a wider range of villains" behind the troubled payroll system than the National MPs whose offices are being picketed by frustrated teachers today.

Members of the New Zealand Educational Institute, representing primary and intermediate teachers, have been protesting outside 35 National MPs' electorate offices this morning.

They have targeted offices the length of the country from Phil Heatley's office in Whangarei to Eric Roy's office in Invercargill, including Education Minister Hekia Parata's office in Porirua.

The picket comes six months after the launch of the Novopay system, which has been plagued by issues each pay cycle including underpayments and, in some cases, no payments at all.

Mr Joyce told TVNZ's Breakfast programme this morning that he understood the teachers' frustration.

But he said there were plenty more people to picket than just National MPs - including former Labour education minister Trevor Mallard and his then adviser Chris Hipkins.

"I understand they want the thing solved, but actually there's a wider range of villains in this ... This problem goes back many years and in fact this is the second pay system which has been difficult."

Mr Joyce said there had been similar issues with the pay system for teachers introduced in the 1990s.

"So there's something about the way we pay our teachers in this country as well which causes a problem whenever the software is changed ... We do have to get to the bottom of that."

Mr Joyce said a lot of work had been put into fixing the Novopay system and a number of errors had been stabilised.

He said 80 bugs had been fixed two weeks ago and another 150 would be fixed in two weeks' time.

"It's still unacceptable levels - roughly just under 2 per cent of the last pay were errors and it should be down around half to 1 per cent in a mature pay system.

"And that's an important thing to point out, too. There's always errors in a pay system and in fact this time last year, the old system was delivering about five or six hundred teachers that weren't being paid."

Asked if he still had faith in Talent2, the company which built the Novopay system, Mr Joyce said "maybe" - but there was a long way to go.

Mr Joyce said there should be no teachers who was not getting paid.

"The system is obviously not delivering pay for some people, but there are systems in place to make sure that people get paid immediately afterwards if there's a problem."

Some schools were also making payments to teachers.

NZEI president Judith Nowotarski said the union had been to weekly meeting with Mr Joyce but had not seen a reduction in the level of frustration from members.

Ms Nowotarski said the action would not interrupt the school day.

The union wants the Government to agree to a package of support measures for schools, and to ensure adequate staffing and service levels at Novopay and the Ministry of Education.

 

Consumer Guarantees precedent

Rob Fischer asks, re the Novopay fiasco, "Who would you blame: the person who built a shoddy toaster or the person who sold it to you knowing it was shoddy?"  Today you take it back to the person/firm you dealt wit.,Iit's they who must repair, replace or refund.  Then they go to the next person up the line to compensate them appropriately.  It is no longer OK to say to your retail customer - the end user of the product - "you'll have to send it to the manufacturer, there's nothing I can do about it".
Teachers are in a difficult position because their direct employer is not Novopay, nor the government, yet the Board that hired them is as powerless as they to deal with this mess.  I realise that the law here is different from retail which is covered by the Consumer Guarantees Act.  However it is a good model, and I suggest the law be alteed to include more of these cases where the victims have a complex chain linking them to the company that has caused their distress.  It would prevent other links in the chain from taking the convenient option of standing aside saying they can do nothing, it's not on their patch.

More than shoddy

Obviously it should never have been rolled out - my teacher friend who hasn't been paid since before Xmas would probably say it is more than just "shoddy".

In the end the buck stops with the minister and no amount of dodging and ducking is going to change that. The politicians were told there were big problems and decided to deploy it anyway, and they did it  nationwide rather in a few schools to help iron out the problems and minimise the disruption.

Villains

Yes, there may be other villains involved but that doesn't absolve National from the responsibility of having launched it knowing it had multiple flaws. Who would you blame: the person who built a shoddy toaster or the person who sold it to you knowing it was shoddy?

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Green AcresDunedinHome & Garden Maintenance
St Johns Court MotelMiltonMotels
O'Callaghan & Walker Builders Ltd Registered Master BuildersCromwellBuilders
Shoe ClinicQueenstownFootwear