Most New Zealanders have embraced the proposal to guarantee a
holiday for Waitangi and Anzac Days, though some have argued
it is a costly, ineffectual policy which would penalise
anyone who did not work Monday to Friday.
Labour MP David Clark's "Mondayisation" bill passed its
second reading despite National voting against it, and it is
expected to pass into law.
It will ensure that when Waitangi Day or Anzac Day fall on a
Saturday or Sunday, employees will still get a Monday off if
they do not work at the weekend.
Workers and the public almost unanimously supported the bill
in submissions, while businesses' responses were mixed. A
survey by Hospitality New Zealand of its members revealed
they were evenly divided.
The Retailers Association, Business NZ and the Hospitality
Association all pointed to the increased cost to companies
through reduced productivity and a day's paid leave.
The cost of having an extra day off every seven years was
estimated to be 0.11 per cent of the average wage bill.
Unions argued the costs would be so minimal that most
businesses would not notice them.
The government labour service estimated each extra day off
would cost NZ $200 million but has since said this was an
Some submitters argued the legislation was unfair on
employees who worked an irregular roster, because they would
not get the Mondays off.
The Retailers Association said: "There are vast numbers of
people who work weekends, or perhaps Tuesday to Thursday.
None of these people have enjoyed 11 public holidays, ever,
as most holidays have been "Mondayised" in the past,
stripping them of that entitlement."
But Dr Clark assured the select committee considering his
bill that it was drafted in such a way that no one would be
If the national holidays fell on a weekend, and the day would
otherwise be a working day for an employee, the public
holiday had to be treated as falling on that day. Anyone
working on a weekend Anzac or Waitangi Day had to be paid
time and a half and accrue a day in lieu.
The main economic argument in favour of the bill was that it
was believed the extra holiday would boost the local tourism
Tourist operators said hotels sold 1.5 more rooms each during
A holiday park at Hot Water Beach said it booked 457 people
on a long weekend in 2012 compared with 72 bookings in 2011
when Waitangi Day fell on a weekend.
Some submitters argued that it was narrow-minded to discuss
the pros and cons of additional holidays in purely economic
The Dunedin Community Law Centre noted that New Zealanders
worked more annual hours than workers in Britain, Canada,
Japan and Canada and giving workers more time with families
could provide significant gains in physical and mental
Boost to domestic tourism from additional holidays.
Potential for increased productivity from rested workers.
Mental and physical benefits of workers having more days
off/time with families.
Opportunity for additional events to commemorate national
Creates consistency with Christmas, Boxing Day, New Year's
Impact on employers is minimal.
Would make no significant difference because many people work
Potential cut to productivity from reduced working days.
Takes attention away from special nature of the nationally
Penalty rate makes it uneconomic for some businesses to open
on public holidays.
New complications for companies in pay entitlements.
- Isaac Davison of the New Zealand Herald