Labour leader David Cunliffe has defended himself against
accusations he misled the public over his party's proposed
$60-a-week child payment scheme.
In his State of the Nation address on Monday, Mr Cunliffe set
out a policy to give most parents of newborn babies a payment
of $60 a week until that baby turns 1, while those on middle
and lower incomes would continue to receive the payment until
the child turns 3.
He said the first year payments would apply for those with
household incomes of less than $150,000 a year, which Labour
estimated will be about 59,000 households or 95 per cent of
children aged under one.
Labour also plans to extend Paid Parental Leave from 14 to 26
What Mr Cunliffe failed to clarify in the speech was that
parents won't be eligible for the $60 dollar a week baby
bonus while they're on paid parental leave.
He told TV3's Firstline this morning that he denied
misleading the public.
"Our materials which we published at the time of the speech
made clear right from the get-go that people have a choice;
they can either take the baby bonus ... for the whole year,
which they're entitled to do ... that's what the speech said,
or - if they are also eligible - they can choose to be on
Paid Parental Leave, which is a greater amount. So they're
never going to be worse-off than the $60 dollars a week.
"One word in the speech could have been different - 'will' or
'can' - not a big drama.
"We've been absolutely frank and absolutely clear in all the
materials for this speech that people have the choice between
going on the $60 a week for the whole first year or taking
Paid Parental Leave if they qualify. They can't do both. At
no point have we said that they could do both."
Speaking on Firstline yesterday, Prime Minister John Key
attacked Mr Cunliffe's credibility.
He accused the Labour leader of "misleading New Zealanders"
over the proposed child payment scheme.
"David Cunliffe's developing a reputation around Parliament
for being very tricky," Mr Key said.
"He [Cunliffe] just needs to learn to be up front with the
public so they can actually trust his word.
Mr Cunliffe said today the Government is losing the argument
in substance, "so they're indulging in disappointing,
- Additional reporting by Claire Trevett