Mallard's moa 'not a goer'

Trevor Mallard: 'I'm absolutely certain that at some point in the future, a whole pile of species that area currently extinct will be brought back to life.'
Trevor Mallard: 'I'm absolutely certain that at some point in the future, a whole pile of species that area currently extinct will be brought back to life.'
Moa up to 1.8m tall roaming the Rimutaka Forest Park above Wainuiomata could be a reality in the next 50 to 100 years and a tourism boost for the local community, but raising the idea has opened local Labour MP Trevor Mallard to ridicule.

"We could again see a snapshot of New Zealand as it once was before the arrival of humans," Mr Mallard told the Wainuiomata Business Development Breakfast this morning.

"I know that this all sounds a bit like a scene from Jurassic Park. But it is going to happen."

Mr Mallard extolled the breakthroughs in science around bringing back extinct species, highlighting the Spanish bucardo ibex and the gastric-brooding frog in Australia as examples.

The ibex was crossed with a related species and the resulting embryo was brought to term, though the animal died shortly after birth. The frog egg successfully divided several times, though did not form a viable foetus.

Labour leader David Cunliffe did little to support his caucus colleague's suggestion.

"I don't think this one's going to fly. There's a lot of scientific work to go under the bridge before moas are going to be flopping around in Wainuiomata.

"The moa's not a goer."

Prime Minister John Key joked that there were a few moas in the Labour caucus already, while senior minister Steven Joyce facetiously called it "inspired thinking".

"Why stop there? Why not bring back some old Labour Party prime ministers ... some extra talent for their caucus. This is a huge vista of opportunity," Mr Joyce said.

But Mr Mallard insisted de-extinction was inevitable.

"I'm absolutely certain that at some point in the future, a whole pile of species that area currently extinct will be brought back to life ... The moa will be a goer, but we're talking to 50 to 100 years out."

He stressed that he did not want 240kg, 3.5m-tall moa roaming the hills behind Wainuiomata.

"They would be dangerous. But the ones 1.3m-tall (and 1.8m-tall) don't weight much more than turkeys. I'd like ones I could pat on the head, rather than the ones that are going to bowl us over."

He said there were parallels with Jurassic Park, "which of course most of us thought of as absolutely impossible and ridiculous".

"I'm absolutely serious that we should be taking advantage of science as it develops. A lot of people pooh-poohed early scientists, but this work is something which is logical, it is already happening around the world, and in New Zealand ... we should at least start talking about it."

He said it was not official Labour Party policy, nor a diversion from more important political issues.

"I don't think this is a distraction at all. It's a minor, long-term idea."

- Derek Cheng of the New Zealand Herald

All Black DNA

How about "bring back Buck"?

Not a joke

Why is this idea being held up to ridicule? It may not be technically possible now. However if science advances to the point where this can be done, then it seems a perfectly sensible idea to me.

Unfortunately DNA is a long chain molecule. Once it breaks into pieces, putting them back together is going to be a big challenge. Wouldn't it be great to be able to bring back some extinct species? Perhaps dinosaurs are too long gone, but moa, the Tasmanian Tiger and other recent just losses might be reversable.  So I'm not laughing at Trevor Mallard. The idea is a good one.

Emu + Moa = Emoa

Finding viable DNA is the big problem. You do realise the Greens wouldnt let it out of the lab, don't you Trev? Which brings about the "no genetically altered organisms" stance they have. [Abridged]

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Remarkables Park Surgery FranktonMedical Centres
Mainfreight LimitedDunedinTransport & Haulage
L.M Wright & Co Ltd Importers & Manufacturers AgentsDunedinBusiness Services
Paterson & Poland (2000) LtdDunedinIndustrial Supplies