The British government has been accused of dragging its feet
over reforms to the pub industry after it rejected calls from
opposition politicians to commit to new laws forcing big pub
firms to treat tenants fairly.
In the UK, where almost half of the 50,000 pubs are run by
tenants on closely controlled terms with landlords, many pubs
have been forced to shut due to small margins and fierce
competition from much cheaper supermarkets. Latest figures
show 26 pubs are closing every week.
Lawmakers want a code backed by law to prevent firms with 500
or more tenanted pubs like Enterprise Inns, Greene King and
Punch Taverns from abusing the "beer tie", under which such
pubs are forced to buy beer from the firms who hold their
leases, often at high prices.
To ensure fair beer prices and also rent, an adjudicator
would be appointed with powers to fine.
The Conservative-led coalition government outlined proposals
for such a code last April and launched a public consultation
whose outcome is now months overdue.
The opposition Labour Party on Tuesday criticised ministers
for acting too slowly and called for them to pledge to
introduce the laws before the May 2015 general election.
"For all the warm words expended on the floor of this house
and elsewhere, still, in legal terms, nothing has changed,"
Labour pubs spokesman Toby Perkins told a parliamentary
"It seems that no evidence is good enough for them to
recognise the reality of what people are seeing in their
The government said it agreed on the need for reforms, but
that it would not commit to new laws until it had digested
the findings of its consultation, which closed later than
planned in December.
"There is no attempt to kick this into the long grass. We're
trying to do this properly," Business Minister Vince Cable
He said any decisions would be based on the outcome of the
consultation and that he could not second-guess the
government's response to it.
While the government says the code would save tenants 100
million pounds ($164 million) in total a year, Enterprise has
argued it would lead to reduced investment, resulting in
increased pub closures and shutting off the industry to new
entrants seeking a low cost way to enter the market.
Greene King, which has the majority of its 1,200 pubs run on
a beer-tie agreement, has warned that if the code became too
costly it could reduce the number of its tenanted pubs to
become exempt from the regulation.