Belgium approves child euthanasia

An electronic voting board shows the results of a vote on a law to allow euthanasia for terminally ill children of any age at the Belgian Parliament in Brussels. REUTERS/Francois Lenoir
An electronic voting board shows the results of a vote on a law to allow euthanasia for terminally ill children of any age at the Belgian Parliament in Brussels. REUTERS/Francois Lenoir
Belgium has become the first country to allow euthanasia for terminally ill children of any age with its lower house of parliament passing new "right-to-die" legislation by a large majority.

The law goes beyond Dutch legislation that set a minimum age of 12 for children judged mature enough to decide to end their lives. It has popular support in Belgium, where adult euthanasia became legal in 2002.

In the Chamber of Representatives, 86 lawmakers voted in favour, 44 against and 12 abstained. Most opposition parties supported it, as well as the governing socialists and liberals.

One man in the public gallery shouted "murderers" in French when the vote was passed.

The Christian Democrats, although members of Prime Minister Elio Di Rupo's coalition, voted against. Christian, Muslim and Jewish leaders denounced the law ahead of the vote in a rare joint declaration and Catholic bishops have led days of prayer and fasting against it.

"This is not about lethal injections for children. This is about terminally ill children, whose death is imminent and who suffer greatly," said Carina Van Cauter, a lawmaker for the Flemish Liberal Democrats who back the law.

"There are clear checks and balances in the law to prevent abuse," she said of the legislation, which now has to pass the largely symbolic stage of being signed by the country's monarch.

"SLIPPERY SLOPE"

The vote has attracted more attention abroad than in Belgium, where none of the major newspapers carried the news of Thursday's vote on their front pages, and television news concentrated on Belgium being in the international spotlight.

Children seeking to end their lives must be "capable of discernment", the law says, and psychologists must test them to confirm they understand what they are doing. Parents must also approve of their child's decision.

Supporters of the law say these safeguards would rule out the very young and teenagers not mature enough to decide.

Opponents have dismissed these rules as arbitrary and warned the new law will lead to a slippery slope of ever wider interpretation and a "banalisation" of euthanasia.

Brussels Archbishop Andre-Joseph Leonard, head of the Catholic Church in Belgium, asked at a prayer vigil last week why the state wanted to give minors such responsibility when they had to wait until 18 for many other legal rights.

"The law says adolescents cannot make important decisions on economic or emotional issues, but suddenly they've become able to decide that someone should make them die," he said.

Belgium's rules on euthanasia have come under international scrutiny in the past year after it granted the right to die to deaf twin brothers who were about to turn blind and to a transgender person after an unsuccessful sex change operation.

The new law specifies that children seeking euthanasia must be terminally ill rather than just in a state of unbearable suffering, which is the qualification for adults.

FEW EXPECTED TO OPT TO DIE

Belgian nurse Sonja Develter, who has cared for some 200 children in the final stages of their lives since 1992, said she opposed the law.

"In my experience as a nurse, I never had a child asking to end their life," Develter told Reuters before the vote.

But requests for euthanasia did often come from parents who were emotionally exhausted after seeing their children fight for their lives for so long, she added.

In practice, supporters of child euthanasia say, there are likely to be few minors who will be allowed to die.

The Netherlands has had five cases of child euthanasia since the law went into effect there in 2002. The total number of Dutch euthanasia cases has been 2,000 to 4,000 a year.

Between 2006 and 2012, there was just one case of a Belgian under the age of 20 requesting euthanasia. Over 1,000 people opt for euthanasia in Belgium annually.

Apart from Belgium and the Netherlands, euthanasia is also legal in neighbouring Luxembourg, and France is considering legalising it later this year. Switzerland allows assisted suicide if the person concerned takes an active role.

In the United States, assisted suicide is legal in Montana, Oregon, Vermont and Washington states.

Children's rights

Of course, H, but what if advances in medical science lead to more effective treatment? Are you seriously suggesting being on Struggle Street with assoc depression are grounds for Euthanasia? My point is, adult caregivers would need to introduce the idea. It is not in a child's worldview to voluntarily consider euthanasia. The concept cannot be chalked up as respecting a child's wish.

Some children live from day to day

And so do some adults, the ones whose pay burns a hole in their pocket, treats and fun on payday, scrabbling down the back of the sofa in the 2 days before next pay.  I do not think this is a valid argument against allowing children to have their wishes respected, though not automatically acted upon any more than adults' are.

I was a child once.  I had definite feelings of fear of future events.  I understood why my parents told me not to scratch my chickenpox because it would leave scars and marks lasting the rest of my life.  Had I had an incurable illness I would have understood that, unlike the maddening itch of chickenpox, there was no point in putting up with misery for the sake of my future life.  

Putting the question

Children live from day to day, especially with terminal illness. I am convinced the ending of life is an adult concept, which would have to be suggested to the child. It is wrong to portray this law as a Childrens' Right.

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Filadelfio'sOamaruRestaurants
Keith Mackenzie Builder LtdCromwellBuilders
You’ll Say Wow Carpet CleaningDunedinCleaners
Lake Wanaka BabysittingWanakaChildcare & Kindergartens