Click photo to enlarge
Graphic diagrams Bernard Madoff's cell at the Metropolitan
Correctional Center.
Bernard Madoff went from a US$7 ($NZ13.4) million
penthouse to a tiny jail cell with cinderblock walls and
linoleum floors after confessing he carried out what may be the
biggest fraud in Wall Street history to escape the pain of a
recession.
The change in lifestyle for the 70-year-old financier was
welcomed on Thursday by angry investors who packed into a
federal courtroom to watch Madoff plead guilty to cheating
nearly 5,000 investors out of billions of dollars.
"I am painfully aware that I have deeply hurt many, many
people, including the members of my family, my closest
friends, business associates and the thousands of clients who
gave me their money," he told US District Judge Denny Chin.
"I cannot adequately express how sorry I am for what I have
done," he said just before Chin ordered him to prison to
await a June 16 sentencing when he will face up to 150 years
in prison.
His lawyers filed a notice of appeal to a federal appeals
court to get it to reconsider Chin's decision.
Defence attorney Ira Sorkin argued Madoff deserved to stay
out because other high-profile financial criminals accused in
multi-billion-dollar frauds were not jailed until sentencing,
but Chin disagreed, telling prosecutors he did not even need
to hear their bail arguments.
"In light of Mr. Madoff's age, he has an incentive to flee,
he has the means to flee, and thus, he presents a risk of
flight," Chin said.
Madoff said "guilty" repeatedly to 11 felony counts,
including securities fraud and perjury. He could also be
fined and ordered to pay restitution to his victims and
forfeit any ill-gotten gains.
In a long, detailed statement delivered in a soft but steady
voice, Madoff implicated no one but himself in the vast Ponzi
scheme. He said he started it as a short-term way to weather
the early-1990s recession, and was unable to extricate
himself as the years went by.
"I am actually grateful for this opportunity to publicly
comment about my crimes, for which I am deeply sorry and
ashamed," Madoff said in his first public comments about his
crimes since the US$65 billion scandal broke in early
December after he confessed to his sons.
His December 11 arrest turned a well-respected investment
professional - Madoff was once chairman of the Nasdaq
exchange - into a symbol of Wall Street greed amid the
economic meltdown. The public fury toward him was so great
that he sometimes wore a bulletproof vest to court.
The court appearance disappointed many Madoff investors, who
hoped he would say who might have helped him pull off the
scam and where the money went.
Because Madoff pleaded guilty without a deal with
prosecutors, he is under no obligation to cooperate. Some
legal experts and investors, like Judith Welling, have
speculated that he is sacrificing himself to protect his
wife, his family and friends.
"He's trying to save the rest of his family," Welling said.
"We need to find out who else was involved, and we need,
obviously, to freeze the assets of all those people involved
to help the victims."
Acting US Attorney Lev Dassin said in a statement that the
government made no deal, "public or otherwise," with Madoff
over his plea, his sentence or whether it will pursue more
charges against him or anyone else.
There was a smattering of applause after the judge announced
Madoff would go directly to jail - the drab, windowless
high-rise Metropolitan Correctional Center next door to the
courthouse - to await sentencing. But that did not lessen his
victims' anger or satisfy their desire for retribution.
"So he spends the rest of his life in jail - is that justice?
People's lives are ruined," said Adriane Biondo of Los
Angeles, one of five members of her family who lost money
with Madoff. "He's sitting in jail? That's awesome," she said
sarcastically. "Where's the money, Bernie?"
Prosecutors gave assurances they are investigating Madoff's
wife and other family members and employees to determine what
role, if any, they played in scam.
In court documents, prosecutors say Madoff reported he
oversaw US$64.8 billion. However, experts said that the
actual loss was probably much less and that the higher number
reflects the false profits Madoff told investors they were
making. So far, authorities have located only about US$1
billion for investors.
Prosecutors have already said low-level employees in Madoff's
New York offices participated by mailing out tens of
thousands of phony monthly statements and trading
confirmations to make it look as if customers were making
money in the market.
Some investors suspect their money ended up in the hands of
Madoff's wife, Ruth. She was not in court Thursday. But the
mere mention of her name drew jeers and laughter.
His thousands of victims included individuals, trusts,
pension funds, hedge funds and nonprofit organizations. The
scheme wiped out people's fortunes, ruined charities and
foundations, and apparently pushed at least two investors to
commit suicide.
Investors big and small were swindled, from Florida retirees
to celebrities such as Steven Spielberg, actor Kevin Bacon
and Hall of Fame pitcher Sandy Koufax. Many of Madoff's
victims were Jews and Jewish charities, which trusted him
because he is Jewish. Those cheated included Nobel Peace
Prize winner and Holocaust survivor Elie Wiesel.
In court on Thursday, Madoff - clad in a charcoal-gray suit,
with swept-back, wavy gray hair - said he began the scheme
during the last recession, when "I felt compelled to satisfy
my clients' expectations, at any cost." He did not put his
investors' money into the market, as he claimed. Instead, it
was a Ponzi scheme, or a pyramid, in which early investors
are paid off with money taken in from later ones.
"When I began the Ponzi scheme I believed it would end
shortly and I would be able to extricate myself and my
clients from the scheme," he said.
"However, this proved difficult, and ultimately impossible,
and as the years went by I realized that my arrest and this
day would inevitably come."
In Washington, White House spokesman Robert Gibbs said: "The
president is glad that swift justice will happen."
Gibbs said the Obama administration will do everything
possible to ensure strict enforcement of securities
regulations "and hope that through those actions that that
kind of greed and irresponsibility and that kind of criminal
activity never happens again."
"I wanted him to see some of the faces of the people he lied
to and destroyed," said Cynthia Friedman, 59, of Jericho,
N.Y.
She and her husband, Richard, said Madoff defrauded them of
their life savings of $3 million. They learned it was gone
months before Richard Friedman was supposed to retire - a
plan now on hold.
Madoff did not look at any of the three investors who spoke
at the hearing.
Madoff told the court that he falsely told investors he was
employing a "split strike conversion strategy": He claimed he
invested their money in a batch of stocks from the Standard
& Poor's 100 that closely tracked the price movements of
the index.
He also told investors that he would periodically pull their
money out of the market and put it in Treasury bills. And he
claimed he bought stock options to hedge against losses. All
of that was false.
Madoff also said that to fool his clients into thinking he
was buying and selling stocks, he transferred money from his
fraudulent operations into his wholesale stock-trading firm,
which he otherwise described as an honest, legitimate
business.
Afterward, Burt Ross, a lawyer from Englewood, N.J., who lost
US$5 million in Madoff's swindle, said: "It's a little bit
like seeing the devil."