A Melbourne man who was punched in the face by a police
officer has been awarded almost $130,000 in damages after a
judge found his rights had been violated by the "insulting"
attack.
Tim Vivoda was punched while in custody at the Ringwood
police station in April 2008 after being found drunk in a
public place.
He had been drinking at a friend's house when he wandered
outside, fell over and injured himself, before being taken by
police.
The officer who punched him, Senior Constable David Kealy,
said he acted in self-defence, believing Mr Vivoda had been
lunging to grab his pistol and knowing he had a previous
conviction for assaulting police.
But the pistol was not in his holster at the time.
Mr Vivoda was charged with assaulting police but the charge
was later dismissed.
He alleged the charge was brought against him for an improper
purpose constituting malicious prosecution.
Mr Vivoda sued Sen Const Kealy and the state of Victoria for
the psychological injury he suffered as well as medical
expenses and loss of wages.
Judge Christopher O'Neill awarded Mr Vivoda $129,304 in
damages, in the Victorian County Court today.
He said the officer's response was out of proportion to the
threat he faced.
"Even accepting Mr Vivoda was intoxicated at the time and his
behaviour somewhat unpredictable, the realistic prospect of
him attempting to grab an officer's firearm was small," said
Judge O'Neill.
He said the way Mr Vivoda was treated in the custody area of
the police station, after the punch, was insulting and in
contemptuous disregard of Mr Vivoda's rights.
A name, residential address, and (preferably residential) telephone number is required from readers who comment on ODT Online. These details will not be visible to site visitors.