• Ranking achievements . . .
There is nothing left to say about the All Whites except,
maybe, considering where they now rank in modern New Zealand
sport.
Rushing to compile lists comparing one sport to another, one
athlete to another and one era to another can be as pointless
as debating the respective merits of chocolate and cheese.
First you have to accept the 2009 All Whites, while they have
done brilliantly, should not be ranked above the 1982 All
Whites.
The present team basically had to win one game, and that was
at home.
The 1982 team faced the longest qualifying campaign in World
Cup history, both in miles travelled and games played, and
their crunch game was in Singapore.
Best simply to say the 2009 All Whites provided the greatest
moment in New Zealand football SINCE 1982.
But what else in New Zealand team sport can compare in the
last 27 years?
• . . . is not easy
It is tempting to immediately mention the 1987 Rugby World
Cup.
You know, the first and only time the All Blacks could
legitimately claim to be the best in the world.
I'm not convinced.
It was the first tournament, it was hastily assembled,
everybody knew we'd win, South Africa wasn't there and most
of the world didn't really care.
For global performance, I'd look at the Tall Blacks finishing
fourth at the world basketball championships in 2002.
That remains the single most under-rated performance by a New
Zealand team in the modern era.
Seriously, fourth in a genuinely global sport? A New Zealand
team? That's crazy talk.
Our netballers won world titles in 1987 and 2003.
Great effort and all, but fewer than five countries play the
game to any serious level.
Same goes for rugby league.
The Kiwis' win in the World Cup last year was epic, but that
is another sport that has just a few chairs at the top table.
Since the New Zealand men's team won Olympic gold in 1976,
genuine success in hockey has been sporadic - neither the men
nor the women have won an Olympic medal of any colour since
then - and our cricketers have won a Champions Trophy but
have never got past the World Cup semifinals.
Rowing has produced multiple world champion crews, including
the remarkable Evers-Swindell sisters, who won back-to-back
Olympic gold medals.
But do two people make a team?
Michael Campbell and company won the Eisenhower Trophy for
amateur golf in 1992, but golf's great achievements are in
the professional ranks, and while the Black Ferns won three
consecutive women's Rugby World Cups, women's rugby has even
less global profile than men's rugby.
Softball is a contender, with the Black Sox another team to
win three straight world titles.
And, while America's Cup teams appear in court more often
than Millie Elder, Team New Zealand's victories in 1995 and
2000 deserve a mention.
If I stick to ranking the traditional teams (no
Evers-Swindells, in other words), I'd lean towards having
both football squads in a group of five at the top along with
the 1987 All Blacks, the 2002 Tall Blacks and the 2008 Kiwis.
• The obvious headline
Regular
Otago Daily Times reader James Dignan can't believe
we and other newspapers missed the chance to sum up the All
Whites' win against Bahrain with a snappy and obvious phrase.
You will recall the slogan used to promote the game had been
ONE SHOT FOR GLORY.
Then who goes and scores the only goal of the game?
Rory Fallon.
Think about it.
Keep thinking.
Then let it out:
ONE SHOT FOR RORY
• Football came first
I can only assume Alan McDonald was stirring when he had a
crack at FOOTBALL fans in his letter to the editor this week.
McDonald, a rugby and boxing man as well as a serial Dunedin
City Council candidate, admonished the media and "football
people" for "arrogantly" insisting on calling the game
"football".
"Football" in this country means rugby union, he thundered,
and many other football codes had the right to use the word.
If he is not kidding, McDonald - with whom I have had regular
email correspondence over the years; no doubt there will be
one from him in my inbox by Monday - is regurgitating the
sort of dusty thinking that makes blinkered rugby fans look
like miserable killjoys.
The fact is that football was football before any of the
other footballs were invented, so the sport has a reasonable
claim to the word.
Also, modern rugby folk do not use "football" when referring
to their sport any more.
They just don't.
Finally, like the vast majority of the world's population,
New Zealanders are getting their heads around using
"football" and not "football".
It sounds better.
It makes us feel part of the world football family,
dysfunctional as it may be.
The national body is called New Zealand Football, and the
national league is called the New Zealand Football
Championship.
Many media outlets have decided to go with "football".
In our newspaper, as in others, there has been a gradual
shift to the point where some stories have both "football"
and "football".
Perhaps it is time the ODT sports editor follows the wishes
of the people and makes an official style change. Football it
is!
• A Tiger tale
The excitement generated
in Australia by the visit of world golf No 1 Tiger Woods did
not convince Golf Magazine senior editor Mike
Walker.
In a mock letter published this week, Walker focused on the
lack of reaction to Tiger hurling a club into the ground that
subsequently bounced into the crowd.
"Thankfully, nobody was injured.
Were it not for his fabled competitiveness, Woods would have
apologised to his fans and verified that everyone was OK
before walking down the fairway.
"Because of Mr Woods's stature and your position as
reporters, we realise that it must be tempting to relate this
incident to the world at large.
However, we'd like to remind you that Mr Woods occupies an
exalted position in the golfing world, and it is of the
utmost importance to the game that his public persona remains
unblemished.
"In fact, if Mr Woods were subject to criticism for this
incident he would consider demanding that Tour events in
which he deigns to participate be played at dawn and be
closed to all media and fans except a small group of
celebrity athlete friends.
"We appreciate your co-operation in the matter.
"In exchange for your silence on the unpleasantness in
Australia on Saturday, Mr Woods might acknowledge you by name
at some future date.
"He will also consider saying something noteworthy at a
future media conference.
"If you need to file a story this week, we'd be happy to
provide you with quotes from Mr Woods about the new Gillette
Fusion Razor. It really is the future of shaving."
hayden.meikle@odt.co.nz
Bookmark/Search this post with:
A name, residential address, and (preferably residential) telephone number is required from readers who comment on ODT Online. These details will not be visible to site visitors.