Commission to hand over mosque attacks report

The gunman attacked the Al Noor mosque during Friday prayers in March last year. Photo: ODT files
The gunman attacked the Al Noor mosque during Friday prayers in March last year. Photo: ODT files
After nearly 20 months and numerous extensions, the high-level investigation into the Christchurch terror attack will today hand over its findings.

Brenton Tarrant's shock guilty plea earlier this year for the deadly attacks on two mosques on March 15, 2019 meant no trial and the Royal Commission's report will offer some of the only insight into how exactly the shootings were able to take place.

Fifty-one people died as a result of the attacks and about 40 more were injured.

Minister of Internal Affairs Jan Tinetti. Photo: RNZ
Minister of Internal Affairs Jan Tinetti. Photo: RNZ
Two commissioners, Sir William Young and Jacqui Dean, were tasked with looking at the gunman's activities in the lead up to March 15, what security agencies knew about him, what - if anything - they did with that information, if those agencies could've prevented the shootings and what should be done to stop similar attacks in future.

Their report and findings will be handed to Governor-General Patsy Reddy and Minister of Internal Affairs Jan Tinetti today, who must then present the report to the House as soon as practicable.

The minister anticipates, but can't guarantee, that will happen before Christmas.

"We're anticipating that this report is going to be quite lengthy, so there is going to be a lot of working through in that process," Tinetti said.

It is possible the families of the victims and survivors could read the report before the wider public, Tinetti said, but added that would ultimately be a decision for the prime minister.

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern will also decide how much of the report is made public, but the Royal Commission has prepared it so no redactions are necessary.

Aya Al-Umari with her parents at the gunman's sentencing earlier this year. Photo: Stuff / Pool
Aya Al-Umari with her parents at the gunman's sentencing earlier this year. Photo: Stuff / Pool

Another piece of the puzzle

Aya Al-Umari is still adjusting to life without her brother, Hussein, and describes the Royal Commission's report as another "piece of the puzzle" for her and her family.

Hussein was murdered by the terrorist at Al Noor Mosque in Christchurch on March 15 last year. His sister hopes the findings will help ensure a similar attack never happens again in New Zealand.

"My one and only brother Hussein is gone and it is important for me that no sibling should have to go through what I went through, and no mother or father should have to bury their child in this manner," Al-Umari told RNZ.

She is intrigued to see what the report will contain and hopes it will encourage New Zealanders to reflect and ask themselves questions like, "what can I do to reduce hatred or what can I learn?"

Multiple delays mean the delivery of the report is happening almost a year later than first expected, but Al-Umari is confident this means the investigation didn't overlook key areas.

"Having the report back as soon as possible wouldn't have bought our loved ones back or it wouldn't have escalated the recovery of the injured or the traumatised victims," Al-Umari said.

"The report did take however long it needed to take to have a quality outcome - I would rather that for the betterment of our future and safety."

Like many others, Al-Umari wants the report released publicly before the end of the year and is also hopeful the government commits to all of the Royal Commission's recommendations as soon as possible.

Nearly 400 people have been interviewed by the inquiry. Photo: RNZ
Nearly 400 people have been interviewed by the inquiry. Photo: RNZ

Behind closed doors

While the questions the Royal Commission would look to answer have been clear, what's been discovered along the way is almost a complete mystery.

Nearly 400 people have been interviewed by the inquiry, including the terrorist, the Prime Minister, representatives from Muslim communities, members of police, foreign experts, the heads of the country's spy agencies and gun lobbyists.

But strict suppression orders, which went as far as to ensure any communication or evidence provided by every single government agency and entity be kept secret, have blanketed the inquiry's work - and the contents of those interviews - from the very start.

This secrecy has been widely scrutinised, with many fearing it would prevent state agencies from being properly held to account - but it wasn't surprising. Staff were working with highly sensitive information from the country's spies, the Government and its agencies.

RNZ has been told some material was so sensitive, it was only viewed by a few people with specific clearance in a secure room at one time.

It wasn't just highly sensitive material the inquiry was working through, it also received more than 1000 public submissions - but they too will be kept secret.

Twenty-nine were made by members of Muslim communities and people directly affected by the attacks, while about 800 submissions were sent in by people linked to an organised firearm campaign.

At least two groups, however, took the unusual step of releasing their submissions publicly, revealing the complex and conflicting perspectives the inquiry has had to consider.

The Council of Licensed Firearms owners told the Royal Commission increased police resourcing and better management of the Arms Act is needed, rather than stricter firearm legislation.

While the Islamic Women's Council claimed the shootings might not have happened, if it weren't for the failures of agencies like the security intelligence service and police.

The council's lengthy submission detailed the group's interactions with numerous government agencies over many years and offered 40 recommendations, including an apology for the failings of government agencies in relation to the attack.

Flower and messages of support were laid outside Linwood Ave mosque, a year on from the shootings...
Flower and messages of support were laid outside Linwood Ave mosque, a year on from the shootings. Photo: RNZ

Delay, delay, delay

The complexity of the investigation, difficulty gathering top secret information and the Covid-19 pandemic mean the inquiry is handing over its final report almost a year later than first expected.

The inquiry was set to complete its work eight months after its establishment in December last year. But soon after the Royal Commission got to work, its timeline was criticised by those closest to it.

The group of Muslims guiding the inquiry, known as the Muslim Reference Group, described the original timeline as "unrealistic" and said it severely undermined the "complexity and gravitas" of the investigation.

In a letter sent to the former Internal Affairs Minister, Tracey Martin, the group explained how the short investigation didn't allow adequate time for the community to grieve and to focus on Ramadan and Hajj.

The group's calls were backed by the Federation of Islamic Associations and the Royal Commission itself and as a result, Cabinet ministers agreed to give the inquiry a new deadline of April 30.

But just as the Royal Commission entered the final month of its investigation, it too was impacted by the Covid-19 crisis.

Officials working at home in lockdown were unable to access crucial classified information and struggled to get responses to draft sections of the report from agencies that were focusing on the pandemic response. Cabinet gave the inquiry two more months - until July - its second extension.

Martin later agreed to one final extension, until the end of November, to allow time for all relevant individuals and state sector agencies impacted by Covid-19 to respond.

And today, after nearly 20 months, the Royal Commission will hand over its final report.

Add a Comment

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter