New bid for mercy by Scott Watson likely

Scott Watson
Scott Watson
Scott Watson will most likely lodge a new application with the Governor-General for the royal prerogative of mercy, his lawyer says.

"It is one of the options open that we are currently actively considering," lawyer Kerry Cook told the New Zealand Herald today.

Watson is serving a life sentence with a minimum non-parole period of 17 years for the murders of 21-year-old Ben Smart and 17-year-old Olivia Hope on January 1, 1998.

He was granted approval to speak on the record with North & South journalist Mike White in August, subject to conditions related to security and interests of victims.

In the interview, conducted over three days from Rolleston Prison in Canterbury, Watson continued to maintain his innocence, saying he was an "easy target" for police.

Mr Cook said Watson's other options were for a judicial review of the original prerogative and further appeal, but this was very difficult given he has exhausted avenues.

Mr White told Radio New Zealand that Watson was upset with the justice system.

"He feels very upset that he's still in jail despite so much evidence that was presented at trial [is] now being questioned and undermined, yet the authorities are incredibly reluctant to do anything," he said.

"He's hoping that by again bringing his case to public light, that perhaps there'll be some interest from someone who was involved in the case, who might be brave enough to come forward to say something."

When asked if he thought Watson was guilty of the crime, Mr White responded: "Look, I've never taken that step. I'm not God, I wasn't there, I don't know exactly what happened."

However, he said speaking to Watson had swayed his view that he was definitely guilty.

"All I can say is that I've gone on this long arch from being utterly convinced Scott Watson was guilty at the time through to now, doubting the evidence against him and being very unsettled about his conviction," Mr White said.

"The more I've learned about this case...you realise that there's precious little that actually still stacks up as evidence against him."

Smart and Hope vanished after boarding a yacht with a stranger in Marlborough Sounds, but Watson insisted it wasn't him.

Watson said in the interview that he believed he was picked by police because he was an easy target.

"I think it was because I had a criminal record," he told North & South.

"And I was (at Furneaux Lodge) alone and I left alone. I told them that. Basically I was an easy target for them, I was the easiest person that they could pick."

- Lincoln Tan of the New Zealand Herald