PM: Cabinet was asked to consider 500 limit to indoor events

Director-General of Health Ashley Bloomfield asked Cabinet to consider a limit of 500 on larger scale indoor events, Jacinda Ardern says.

The Prime Minister announced yesterday that at 11.59pm on Wednesday Auckland would move to level 2, while the rest of the country moved to alert level 1 just before midnight last night.

At level 1 there are no limits to gathering sizes.

Public health professor Nick Wilson told RNZ's Morning Report heĀ  is concerned this is happening too soon, without the digital technology, like a CovidCard, to support it.

Prof Nick Wilson. Photo: supp[lied
Prof Nick Wilson. Photo: supp[lied
Wilson said an intermediate step to level 1.5 would have been safer.

"So if we have a large outbreak from an indoor event such as a concert or a large gym class that could lead to an uncontrollable community outbreak where maybe another lockdown might be the only control option left.

"The Government is just not being sophisticated enough with its selection of control options and really targeting the highest risks type of settings and really not thinking it through enough."

Ardern said it was the view of Cabinet that there is an alert level framework that has been closely followed, which dictates what alert level 1 means.

"For those larger events, we have a code in place that we have an expectation for large event organisers to implement," she said.

Ardern has asked MBIE to contact organisers of big events to make sure they are complying with the code.

New Zealand hasn't had a history of large scale events being problematic, she said.

Events where people are known to each other and socialising with each other have been a problem, she said.

"Our view is that we shouldn't be moving to alert levels if we have a worry about mass outbreaks but we should be continuing to be vigilant and cautious."

Aucklanders are asked to still wear masks, Ardern said.

Wilson hoped the change in alert levels was not because of "political pressure" and that changes should be guided by a scientific public health response.

"We really want to avoid further lockdown situations," he said.

Border opening
Ardern says the work on quarantine travel with the Cook Islands and Australia has never stopped.

"A number of states would actually meet, broadly speaking, our criteria."

If the Americold cases hadn't appeared and only a couple of quarantine workers had tested positive, Ardern says she wouldn't have considered New Zealand to have had an outbreak.

This is because it is known how the workers contracted the virus.

"We would hold the same bar to Australia as we hold to ourselves."


"Public health professor Nick Wilson told RNZ's Morning Report he is concerned this is happening too soon, without the digital technology, like a CovidCard, to support it", gee this guy would have us constantly living in fear, just as well we don't have academics like him running the country.

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter