Woman started on IVF treatment - but she was already pregnant

Photo: Getty Images / File
Photo: Getty Images / File
A woman's joyful moment of finding out she was pregnant following years of trying was shattered after discovering a fertility clinic had wrongly started her on IVF treatment.

"We were saddened that what should have been an exciting and joyous moment in our life, the occurrence of a spontaneous pregnancy, turned into a very stressful and concerning time for us," the woman told the deputy health and disability commissioner Rose Wall.

Today the health watchdog released a report finding Fertility Associates in breach of the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights the failure.

The woman and her husband's story started in June 2017 when a blood test conducted by Fertility Associates suggested she might already be pregnant.

Those results were not passed on to the doctor, who then approved the woman starting medication for her IVF cycle.

She had been on the treatment for just over a week when she discovered she was pregnant.

It is not clear from the HDC report if the error impacted her pregnancy in any way but the Herald has requested this information.

An HDC spokeswoman said: "The family did not report to the HDC that the baby suffered any harm."

The couple contacted Fertility Associates four times to express concern and was ignored each time.

"We have now asked four times to have the last cycle blood results, and it looks like you have finally provided them but in your own spreadsheet as opposed to the [medical laboratory's] format of the other cycles. It seems that you have been withholding these results from us. Please send through the last fertility cycle blood test results in the format as sent from [the medical laboratory]," the woman's husband emailed on the fourth attempt to contact Fertility Associates.

While the couple told the commissioner, they were "confident" that there had been a deliberate cover-up of the mistake, Fertility Associates said that was not true.

The woman and health professionals have not been named in the report due to privacy reasons.

"We reject the accusation that we were somehow covering up providing the results to [Mr and Mrs A]," Fertility Associates told HDC.

A independent specialist assigned to review the case told HDC: "The bottom line is that [IVF] treatment should not have been started if staff were aware of the elevated progesterone levels."

The specialist said it suggested a lack of rigour in clinical practice by those making the decision to treat.

"The only excuse is that pregnancy in a couple with repeated fertility treatments is a rare event," the independent doctor said.

The Deputy Commissioner was also critical of Fertility Associates' failure to disclose the error.

"This case highlights the importance of robust test-ordering protocols and effective communication between providers to ensure quality of services, as well as the importance of openly and honestly disclosing information about errors that occur during the provision of a healthcare service," Wall said.

As a result of the investigation, Wall told Fertility Associates to provide evidence of a new test-ordering protocol, and to conduct an audit of staff compliance with that new protocol in place.

She also recommended that it review HDC's Guidance on Open Disclosure Policies and identify areas for improvement in its practice.

Fertility Associates was told by the deputy commissioner to apologise to the family.

In the report, a Fertility Associates spokesperson said: "It was not our intent to provide treatment that did not meet expectations, or to provide any additional stress during subsequent communications."



Fertility Associates proves you don't need them.

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter