Woman struck by e-scooter left bleeding under bus

Debra Christensen's head was left bleeding and wedged against the wheel of a bus this morning after she was knocked out by a Lime scooter rider near Auckland's Victoria Park.

Her distraught husband, Paul Charman, spoke to the New Herald Herald about the terrifying incident from Auckland City Hospital's emergency department.


The incident comes less than 12 hours after a man riding a Lime scooter was killed on the same road.

Charman said his wife was rushed to hospital after she got off the bus on Fanshawe St, opposite Victoria Park, and was struck by the Lime scooter.

"She doesn't remember what happened after that because she was knocked out cold.

"Her head was under the wheel of a bus, that's how bad it was," Charman said.

He said his wife, who was a keen mountain climber and adventure-lover, had lacerations to her face and skull and they were awaiting head scans to see if there had been any further damage.

It was possible she also had broken ribs.

Charman said the bus driver was so shaken by the incident he had to finish his shift.

A witness at the scene described seeing Christensen lying on the ground bleeding after being hit by a young person riding a Lime scooter.

"It is absolute madness to allow those things on footpaths - is it going to take the death of someone's child before they get banned?" the male witness said.

Charman said the crazy thing was when they got to hospital, another person was also there with head injuries after getting hit by a Lime scooter.

"He was a fit young man who was biking on a cycleway when a Lime scooter knocked him out from behind," Charman said.

He said people should feel safe on footpaths, not scared they might be hit by a Lime scooter.

"They are unstable and we need a university to do a study to test their stability. This shouldn't be happening," Charman said.

St John confirmed they were called to the incident on Fanshawe St at 8.47am today.

"We responded with one ambulance and transported one patient in a moderate condition to Auckland Hospital," a spokeswoman said.

Last night a 59-year-old man was killed while riding a Lime scooter along the same road

It was the first fatal accident involving the controversial e-scooters in New Zealand.

Auckland councillor Christine Fletcher has called for "a complete review" of the e-scooters in a bid to introduce tighter safety regulations.

But Transport Minister Phil Twyford says it is too soon to say if the death of a man on a Lime scooter will prompt tighter e-scooter safety rules.

"I think it would be premature to make any comment about the circumstances of this incident or any implications it might have for safety regulation until we know more about what exactly happened."

Twyford said his thoughts were with the family of the man who died.

The Government already has work underway on assessing the safety regulations of Lime and other such e-scooters, which is being led by Associate Transport Minister Julie Anne Genter.

"That will include rules about where Lime scooters can be used in terms of speed limits," Twyford said.

A Lime spokeswoman this morning said the company was "devastated to learn of this tragic incident in Auckland overnight, and our thoughts are with the victim's family and friends during this extremely difficult time."

She said the company had been in contact with local authorities and would continue to assist however possible.


The crazyness of allowing those things on a footway beggars belief, The assumption has been that because they exist then they have to be allowed. Footpaths are no longer safe. At the end of the day it is all about a very tasty revenue generating business with a thin coating of "green" warm fuzzy. Older folk and children are the most vulnerable. It is only a matter of time before a toiddler gets seriuosly maimed or killed. But its all good! Business is thriving! .....and scooters are so green!

This government appears driven only by photo opportunities for the Prime-mistress. Until her PR department sees the photo opportunity, nothing will be done.

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter