Kaye quit hours after being urged to go for the leadership

Nikki Kaye
It seemed Nikki Kaye was at a fork in the road on Tuesday: either contest for the leader's role, or walk away from politics.
Nikki Kaye knew she was going to leave politics as she walked out of the caucus room on Tuesday night.

The MP for Auckland Central had started the day as deputy leader, was acting leader by that morning after Todd Muller stood down, and had even been pushed by other National MPs to contest the leadership just hours earlier.

But as National MPs emerged from the caucus room behind new leadership team Judith Collins and Gerry Brownlee, Kaye knew she was done.

"I walked out and came along the Parliament forecourt, and I felt this overwhelming sense that now is the time to leave," Kaye told the Herald.

"I just knew. I can't really explain but I knew when I walked out of that caucus room. I knew my chapter was ending."

Speculation is rife that Kaye's sudden and unexpected departure is because she doesn't want to work under Collins or had a role in the leadership team's mishandling of the Covid patient privacy leak.

Kaye dismisses this.

"I'm very confident of the way I've operated and acted throughout this period, with very difficult circumstances arising. It's got nothing in any shape or form to do with that."

And on Collins: "Not at all, in any shape or form. I back Judith Collins 100 per cent to be prime minister. I will campaign for her. She is a formidable politician and I hope she is prime minister."

Nor is Kaye bailing because of the potential for an inquiry to challenge her previous comment that she hasn't received any confidential Covid patient information from close friend and former party president Michelle Boag.

"I've had nothing to do with that issue. I have acted with complete integrity. It has absolutely nothing to do with that.

"People can run all the conspiracy theories they want, but the truth is I'm choosing to take time for me."

Asked to run for leader

It seemed Kaye was at a fork in the road on Tuesday: either contest for the leader's role, or walk away from politics.

As leader, her liberal blue/green credentials might have had the potential to swing the centre behind National.

She is even sometimes jokingly referred to as a Labour MP in the wrong caucus, an idea she scoffs at.

"That is unfair. I'm certainly liberal blue-green, but I'm centre-right.

"The next generation of New Zealanders, many of them are socially-liberal, they care about the environment, but they also want equality of opportunity and the ability to have reward for effort. If anything I've been representative of many of the next generation of New Zealanders."

Did National MPs ask her to challenge for the leadership?

"Some did, absolutely."

She considered it, including the nature of the role and whether she would have caucus support.

In the end, she told Collins that she supported her bid before the vote because it was what was best for the party.

That's been her driving force in the recent months of upheaval for National, she says.

"It's hard for people to sometimes see this, but whether it was potentially Todd standing [with Kaye as deputy], whether it was me making it clear to Judith that she'd be the best leader, I have tried to what is best for the party and the country.

"Judith is the right leader, right now ... To cause disruption [by contesting] when in my view she's the right person would not have been a good thing."

It was not the future she had envisioned when she signed up to be Muller's deputy in May.

"If the circumstances had been different, maybe I would have been Deputy PM, and that would have been the right thing if potentially circumstances hadn't occurred. But they did.

"This is what I've learned about life. You can't know what's around the corner. All you can do is act in the best way possible. That is what I've tried to do."

She doesn't regret being part of the team that rolled Simon Bridges because she didn't think he could win.

But a lot has changed since then, she says.

"The balance of the calculation shifted for me. I had to balance making a significant contribution to New Zealand versus maybe going off and living a little bit.

"I've always chosen my country and my party, but now it's time to choose me."

Part of that calculation, she says, is her unique perspective from having beaten the breast cancer she was diagnosed with in 2016.

"I've tried to think like I've got 40 years but think like I've got 12 months. It's a pretty good way to look at life."


Well... she did the right thing. Who would want that poisoned chalice except the misnamed crusher. I can see crusher in front of her magic mirror "Mirror mirror on the wall, who is the best leader of them all" and the mirror replying "Jacinda is best and fairest of all" and crusher dipping her apples in the poisoned chalice with that evil grin on her face






Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter