'Bladdergate' creates stink in China and Hong Kong

Of all the weighty issues about self-rule and democracy confronting China and Hong Kong, the former British colony that reverted to mainland control in 1997, who could have imagined it would come to this?

A 2-year-old boy defecating on a Hong Kong sidewalk has elicited an increasingly mean-spirited fight between some mainland Chinese and Hong Kong residents, who are exchanging words, including curses, and threatening to exchange bodily fluids.

It started April 15 when a mainland couple shopping in Hong Kong allowed their toddler to go on a crowded sidewalk in the Mong Kok district. An offended Hong Kong man started to take photos, whereupon the shrieking mother grabbed his memory card and started to scuffle with him on the street. Another Hong Kong man tried to seize the family's stroller.

"Don't you have kids? Don't your kids need to use the toilet?" the mother screamed, while the father held the wailing toddler.

Police arrived and booked the mother on charges of assault and the father on receiving stolen property - to wit, the memory card his wife had seized from the camera.

Waggishly called "Bladdergate" (although video of the child caught in the act shows more than urine involved), the altercation has become a defining incident in the strained relationship.

The stink has hardly dissipated. On Sunday, a dozen or so demonstrators at the giant Harbor City mall in Hong Kong mocked mainlanders by squatting and pretending to defecate on a photo of Mao Zedong and brandishing toilet paper.

One wore a pig mask and another dressed as a Red Guard. A skirmish nearly broke out between the protesters and offended customers and staff, who screamed at one another across the mall's atrium.

The Communist Party's official Global Times weighed in Wednesday, denouncing the Hong Kong protesters as "skinheads" and "hooligans."

"This handful of radicals in Hong Kong remind us of the rampant skinheads and neo-Nazis in Europe. Xenophobia is the cult of these groups," the paper opined. "We need to fight back and overwhelm any forces that try to harm the integrity of the nation."

Hong Kong, which has a population of about 7 million, receives more than four times that many visitors from the mainland each year.

Residents complain that the deluge has left Hong Kong with impassable streets, skyrocketing prices and shortages of consumer goods, especially products like baby formula.

Posters and banners have gone up denouncing the mainlanders as "locusts." Facebook pages are plastered with photographs of visitors engaging in what the British-mannered Hong Kong residents consider uncivilized behavior like eating on subways or allowing children to relieve themselves in the streets, a habit common in the Chinese countryside.

"Many people think this is ridiculous, but it is a serious matter," said one of the activists, 24-year-old Hong Kong-born Sky Ip. "There are big cultural differences between China and Hong Kong, and big political differences. I worry about our future."

Some Chinese mainlanders are fighting back. One mainland blogger last week suggested on a forum hosted by Tianya.cn, "Let's take our children to Hong Kong and let them pee and poo everywhere and let's see which idiot will come and take pictures of us"-a threat that made headlines in Hong Kong media.

The dispute is a boon to punsters and the butt of jokes, but the hostility is not funny to everyone. Chinese authorities have considered a travel advisory warning mainlanders about visiting Hong Kong, according to the Hong Kong-based South China Morning Post.

Anti-mainland activists are planning a protest May 4 at the home of Hong Kong's secretary of commerce and economic development, Greg So Kam-leung, who dared to suggest that Hong Kong residents learn to be more tolerant.

According to one advertisement for the protest, supporters are urged to relieve themselves in front of his home-at least using colored water and fake feces.

Add a Comment

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter