If the Government paid to shift people off the flooded south bank at Franz Josef Glacier, landowners living by the sea and in flood plains all over the country would be seeking the same, West Coast-Tasman MP Damien O'Connor says.
West Coast leaders have been fighting publicly over whether to sacrifice the flood-ravaged south side of the Waiho (Waiau) River, in order to save Franz Josef Glacier township on the opposite bank.
Westland Mayor Bruce Smith says the West Coast Regional Council has done nothing, and Mr O'Connor says Mr Smith is playing politics and it is time to stop grandstanding.
One of the unanswered questions is who would pay if the south bank were to be abandoned.
Other issues are the fact Franz Josef sits atop the Alpine Fault - a previous proposal suggested moving the entire township at a cost of $300 million - and whether the state highway and bridge need to be shifted to safer areas.
For now, no one can even agree on the response to the south side flooding.
Mr O'Connor said if the Government was to fully fund compensation to abandon that area, it would have implications of the rest of New Zealand and those in coastal properties and flood plains.
The cost could be "astronomical".
The issue of moving the highway was "first and foremost" for the district and regional councils.
Mr O'Connor said he was committed to fighting for the fairest and most sensible solution.
Asked if the Franz Josef township should be moved off the Alpine Fault, Mr O'Connor said longer term protection of the village would be improved by relieving pressure on the south side and letting the river fan out that way.
"There are technical issues that need to be worked through. There is a huge task facing us all."
The Greymouth Star asked Transport Minister Phil Twyford's office about plans previously drawn up to relocate State Highway 6 on a new deviation through the bush to reconnect with the foot of the Fox Hills at Dochertys Creek, but was referred to the New Zealand Transport Agency.
Mr Smith yesterday defended his role, saying he was out to "protect our people".
"We can't just say 'you're gone' and there's $35 million of investment you walk away from."
Mr Smith said the main stopbank on the south side had been "80 percent washed away".
It was insured by the regional council and therefore it should claim and rebuild and the 83 landowners on the south bank were united in calling for that, he said.
- By Laura Mills
