Franks decision 'a complete joke'

Owen Franks offloads the ball during the All Blacks' game against Australia. Photo: Getty Images
Owen Franks offloads the ball during the All Blacks' game against Australia. Photo: Getty Images
As reported earlier this week, the non-citing of All Blacks prop Owen Franks for his alleged eye gouge incident on Wallabies lock Kane Douglas during Saturday night's test between the sides has not gone down.

Observers of the game from around the world were critical of the decision by SANZAAR to not implement a punishment on Franks for his wrongdoing being labelled 'disgraceful' and 'a sham'.

The backlash against Franks and SANZAAR has not relented since then, with the Daily Mail's Chris Foy voicing his disapproval of the decision to let Franks go unpunished while speaking to Andrew Mulligan on Radio Sport's Crowd Goes Wild Breakfast.

"They've absolutely got away with it, it's a complete joke decision," Foy said.

"Judging by my timeline on Twitter and a lot of the reactions of people I follow or see or speak to, everyone's in agreement.

"I mean I've had former players I've spoken to and heard from, and in this part of the world [the UK], everyone seems completely in agreement, because partly, in Europe, in the United Kingdom, there's been various cases in the past couple of years where things that didn't seem quite as bad examples as that particular offence have ended up with players being cited, go to a hearing, found guilty and banned for a long time when it seemed particularly accidental.

"So then we see those happening, and then we see what happened at the weekend and think 'this is completely inconsistent', which is the thing that infuriates everyone.

"If you go anywhere near that area [the face region], you're in trouble. It doesn't matter if you meant it as a sickening offense. Even if it's an accidental thing.

"We'll sympathize with those people when it's really obvious it's accidental, but they've still been punished by the judiciary for doing that, so then when you see this one, where it looks like he has one go, then he has another go, and you think it's a pretty open and shut case.

"I'm absolutely staggered that they've seen that and not taken any action. It was completely obvious what happened."

Foy went on to criticize the uncertainty and confusion that surrounds the laws of the game.

"One of rugby's problems is there's too many shades of grey about the laws. It's too open to interpretation and debate, that's one of the issues the game has got."

Add a Comment

OUTSTREAM