Rugby: Who was hot and who was not

Ben Smith: A class player who never got rattled.
Ben Smith: A class player who never got rattled.
Another season has finished for the Highlanders. Rugby writer Steve Hepburn rates the main players who took to the paddock.

Ben Smith (15 appearances): As good and consistent as ever. A class player who never got rattled and led the team well 8

Waisake Naholo (8): Season hit by a broken leg after the first game but came back strong and quick. Perhaps was asked to do too much at times but a powerful weapon on the flank 8

Patrick Osborne (16): Osborne was reliable if not as quick as previous years. Sometimes got into bad positions when running the ball up and only scored three tries which is not a great return for a winger 7

Matt Faddes (17): Had some real belters and made a step up after impressing for Otago in the domestic competition last year. Had a game to remember against the Crusaders. Still made too many errors. Top try-scorer with 10, which was impressive 7

Malakai Fekitoa (16): A quiet season for him. Ball security could have been better. But defensively very strong and still a powerful player for the side 7

Rob Thompson (9): Got a chance through injury and looked to have the goods. Had a forgettable game against the Reds and never really got back into the reckoning after that. Lacked a bit of imagination with the ball

Lima Sopoaga (16): Kept up his high standard and at 75% success rate with his goal-kicking, which was one of the best in the competition. Ran well if sometimes overdid the kicking 8

Aaron Smith (16): Played the most minutes of any player (1207) and was, as usual, a huge part of the Highlanders game. At home under the roof and his long pass gave the backs plenty of space. Kicking game sometimes went astray 8

Liam Squire (14): Tough and strong, his play was good enough to win him an All Black jersey. Unlucky to not start the whole season, the victim of a lot of depth in the loose forwards 8

Luke Whitelock (12): Started 12 games and was solid if not spectacular. A tad inconsistent but had a stormer against the Crusaders under the roof. Not the greatest set of hands 7

Shane Christie (11): Troubled by injury at times and never seemed to get a decent run in the team. A respected leader who will want to get more game time with his Tasman side

Elliot Dixon (15): Brought consistency into his game and was rewarded with an All Black jersey. Was perhaps over-used by the end but produced more on attack 8

Dan Pryor (15): Became a super-sub and was very effective off the bench, getting the whole second half on many occasions. Would have been good to see him get a few more starts

Alex Ainley (11): Had a few injury issues but every time he took the field played well. Toiled away and never shirked any responsibility 7

Tom Franklin (15): A break-out year which led to him getting a spot in the All Black camp. Athletic and skillful, with a big motor 8

Joe Wheeler (11): Was rather anonymous. Did his job but was perhaps passed by Franklin and Ainley. Heading to Japan but will be back in 2017 6

Josh Hohneck (15): Again worked hard and stood strong. Moved around a bit from side to side but a reliable player. Off to England to play for Gloucester 7

Siua Halanukonuka (14): With a name that long is never going to be a friend for journalists. Plugged away and got around the field. A late developer who had his season ended when he jumped high for a ball, something props should never do 7

Daniel Lienert-Brown (14): Unsung hero who scored a crucial try against the Chiefs in Hamilton. Not the biggest of men for a prop but held his own in the scrum and hit plenty of rucks 7

Ash Dixon (17): Played every game and there was talk of an All Black call-up. Accurate lineout thrower who tends to play above his weight, not always successfully 7

Liam Coltman (10): Season was cruelly ended by a cheap shot from some Sharks players. Up to then was playing well and lineout throwing was good. Will be looking for a big season with Otago 7

 

Add a Comment

OUTSTREAM