Bromley stench unlikely to cause long-term problems, Canterbury health official says

Canterbury public health chiefs admit people suffering from the Bromley stench are going through hell, but caution a health register might not be the best way to monitor its impact.

Cheryl Brunton. Photo: University of Otago, Christchurch
Cheryl Brunton. Photo: University of Otago, Christchurch
People experiencing nausea, headaches and disrupted sleep are increasingly concerned about long-term exposure to the sulphurous gases coming from a fire-damaged wastewater treatment plant in the suburb.

But Canterbury medical officer of health Cheryl Brunton said while there was evidence people were suffering physically and mentally from the foul smell, long-term problems were "extraordinarily unlikely" at current hydrogen sulphide concentrations.

Brunton's district health board colleague, Dr Lucy D'Aeth told a city council committee it was clear people were struggling.

"For the people who have an acutely sensitive sense of smell, this is hell, we acknowledge that," she said.

The council asked the DHB to consider establishing a health register in response to community concerns about the months-long stench coming from the plant's two burnt-out trickling filters and overloaded oxidation ponds.

Brunton told the council's finance and performance committee a register would be hard to set up and maintain and would not directly address the problem.

"People who are suffering from the effects of the odour are actually very keen and anxious for that to be acknowledged. A health register doesn't actually address people's health needs," she said.

"A register is actually rather a difficult and clumsy way of ensuring that people have access to care."

The symptoms most commonly reported to GPs were nausea, headaches, eye, throat and skin irritation, worsening asthma and disturbed sleep, Dr Brunton said.

"All of those are very consistent with exposure particularly to hydrogen sulphide at the kinds of concentrations that are being measured in the council's monitoring," she said.

The fire-damaged wastewater treatment plant. Photo: Supplied Image / Christchurch City Council
The fire-damaged wastewater treatment plant. Photo: Supplied Image / Christchurch City Council
She said patients had also reported feelings of considerable distress, frustration and powerlessness.

While it was unlikely the health effects would persist long-term at the concentrations measured so far, Dr Brunton said some people would remain particularly sensitive to odour.

"They may experience some of these health effects at very low concentrations in future," she said.

"For those people, it may well be that although the health effects improve they don't completely resolve."

Photo: New Zealand Defence Force, Wellington, New Zealand, CC BY 2.0 via RNZ
Photo: New Zealand Defence Force, Wellington, New Zealand, CC BY 2.0 via RNZ
Wastewater plant staff are still working on a system to do the job of the two trickling filters, but expect to have it completed by next week.

Council head of three waters Helen Beaumont said it could take at least six weeks for the smell from the oxidation ponds to improve.

"We need to wait three weeks for the biomass to establish and then it will take another, at least three weeks and maybe a little longer, for the water to flush through those six ponds," she said.

"It takes a month or so for the water to pass all the way through."

Beaumont said wastewater discharged into the sea was not meeting environmental standards, but tests showed it was not affecting water quality at the beach.

-By Jean Edwards

Local trusted journalism matters - now more than ever

As the Covid-19 pandemic brings the world into uncharted waters, Star Media journalists and photographers continue to report local stories that matter everyday - yours.

For more than 152 years our journalists have provided Cantabrians with local news that can be trusted. It’s more important now than ever to keep Cantabrians connected.

As our advertising has fallen during the pandemic, support from you our reader is crucial.

You can help us continue to provide local news you can trust simply by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter