Amberley tyre fire: Recidivist arsonist sentenced over North Canterbury inferno

Garry Grimmer has appeared in court charged with arson over the Amberley tyre fire. Photo: George...
Garry Grimmer has appeared in court charged with arson over the Amberley tyre fire. Photo: George Heard
The man responsible for a massive fire at a North Canterbury tyre stockpile in January has been sent to prison.

And it can now be reported that it is not the first time he has targeted the site and been convicted of arson after starting a fiery inferno.

Recidivist arsonist Garry Robert Grimmer, 63, appeared in the Christchurch District Court this morning for sentencing before Judge Tom Gilbert.

He had earlier pleaded guilty to setting the fire at a Racecourse Rd property just outside Amberley on January 29.

The "very, very hot" blaze was at the site of the Amberley tyre stockpile which has been controversial over the years.

The tyre stockpile at the Racecourse Rd site. Photo: George Heard
The tyre stockpile at the Racecourse Rd site. Photo: George Heard
Environment Canterbury had been working closely with the Hurunui District Council in recent times to ensure the removal of the pile.

It emerged in court today that just the day before the fire a plan was put in place to move the tyres off the site.

That removal was expected to cost $500,000 but due to the extensive damage from the fire, the cost was likely to double that figure at least.

The land is owned by Warren Hyslop - and his wife Angelique Hyde read a victim impact statement in court.

Hyde said when the fire started she and Hyslop had "no chance to stop it".

All they could do was "wait and watch" which was "soul destroying".

The couple had been committed to shifting the tyre pile and she said due to Grimmer's "unlawful act" that work was now much more significant and extensive.

She said the stress of the situation had caused her to consider suicide and retreat from society.

"My life has become a rollercoaster… you Mr Grimmer have ruined my life," she said.

"You're not fit to be in society."

She said had Grimmer been jailed for the first fire he lit at the site the second never would have happened.

It would now take them until at least 2023 to get the tyres off the property and clean it up.

The court heard that Grimmer had an alcohol dependency and mental health issues.

A marriage break up and other personal stressors resulted in him "ruminating" and becoming fixated on the tyre pile.

"He found himself offending again," said his lawyer Olivia Jarvis.

"His alcohol use increased in and around that time due to his personal stressors which he says are linked to the tyres."

Jarvis said Grimmer's alcohol problem was a "key issue" and would need to be addressed.

"But for his alcohol use, perhaps he would be in a very different situation here... he turns to alcohol and has offending while he was intoxicated.

"The underlying issue is alcohol.... it's clouded his ability to deal with stress in a normal way.

"It's led to him fixating, having an obsession with this tyre pile that led to him setting it on fire."

Grimmer, through his lawyer, publicly apologised for his actions.

He apologised to the land owners as well as the wider community and said he was keen to address his personal issues so he could return to that community and contribute positively.

Grimmer was also convicted of arson after setting fire to the tyres on February 26, 2018.

He lives across the road from the property and the court heard he "snapped" and torched them after watching in horror for two years as the massive black tyre dump grew on leased farmland.

Grimmer - and others in the community - feared that the old tyres were contaminating the land, and could be jeopardising the town's underground water supply.

When Grimmer saw trucks delivering thousands of old tyres he became concerned.

Grimmer phoned authorities and reported his concerns but felt not enough was done in response.

He then took petrol and paper from home, crossed the road and lit a fire in a smaller pile of about 20,000 tyres beside the main pile of 400,000.

The massive took two days to put out.

Police told the court today that Grimmer, having been convicted of an identical offence earlier, knew better than anyone the risk involved in setting the tyres on fire.

The impact on the victims was "profound".

Judge Gilbert said a presentence report documented Grimmer's "sad... fall from grace".

He was once a high functioning person but it was clear life "completely derailed" for him.

He said Grimmer expressed insight into the harm he caused and "regretted" his offending.

"You have got an alcohol issue... I accept that as life has unravelled for you have turned to the bottle," he said.

"It is clear that your offending has had a huge impact... financial, emotional and ongoing, and will continue to be ongoing for the foreseeable."

There were also environmental costs and a significant impact on ratepayers.

Judge Gilbert accepted that Grimmer had mental health issues and his life had "unravelled".

But that was no excuse for his offending.

He noted that the last time Grimmer was sentenced the judge opted for a rehabilitative course of action.

Grimmer then "fell off the wagon" and committed arson a second time.

"It didn't take long for you to light a second and much bigger and more damaging fire," the judge said.

After considering all the matters before him Judge Gilbert said he had to come at the sentencing from a place of "denunciation and deterrence" rather than rehabilitation.

He sentenced Grimmer to three years and four months in prison.

"There is no prospect of reparation," he said.

"The Parole Board will set your conditions of release."





Sponsored Content






Local trusted journalism matters - now more than ever

As the Covid-19 pandemic brings the world into uncharted waters, Star Media journalists and photographers continue to report local stories that matter everyday - yours.

For more than 152 years our journalists have provided Cantabrians with local news that can be trusted. It’s more important now than ever to keep Cantabrians connected.

As our advertising has fallen during the pandemic, support from you our reader is crucial.

You can help us continue to provide local news you can trust simply by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter