Stadium site too expensive

Otago Polytechnic has decided against moving its Institute of Sport and Adventure to the Forsyth Barr Stadium, saying fit-out and lease costs are higher than it can afford.

Relocating the institute from its present building in Union St to the second floor of the stadium was investigated, but a report to today's polytechnic council meeting said the indicative fit-out costs of $800,000 and annual lease costs of at least $75,000 were "higher than we can afford".

The move also posed "too much risk long term due to lack of ownership, the necessary length of occupation to recoup the fit-out costs and some access issues", the report said.

However, the report said the polytechnic still had concerns about the institute's present home as the Union St building was run down, was inefficient, and was on leasehold land.

The report also outlined various possible options for relocating other programmes between buildings at the Forth St campus.

The Design School may be housed in three levels of H Block, on the corner of Union and Forth Sts, allowing the polytechnic to relocate fashion design away from the former Big Fresh supermarket building on Cumberland St, back to the main campus.

It was expected all hospitality and cookery programmes could be accommodated in the Manaaki building on Harbour Tce, allowing all business programmes to be located in D block, also on Harbour Tce.

Another project being assessed was building an extra 600sq m teaching areas into the roof space of G Block, on Union St.

Preliminary estimates put the cost at $575,000, including extending two stairwells, modification of corridors, installation of fire walls and installation of a new lift.

It was possible the sports institute could relocate to that space, the report said.

The polytechnic council would be asked in September to approve plans for stage one of the redevelopment of the School of Art site, the report said.

There are ambitious plans for a $25 million upgrade of the site, bordered by Anzac Ave, Albany St and Reigo Sts, over the next 12 years.

An elderly building on Anzac Ave is being demolished to make way for stage one, a two-storey classroom block of 780sq m to house bachelor of engineering students.

It had been planned to build a 400sq m building at a cost of about $1 million, but the report said it was now planned to almost double the size of the building, with construction and fit-out expected to cost $2.1 million.

Polytechnic chief operating officer Philip Cullen yesterday said the construction time-frame was "tight but do-able" and it was hoped the building would be complete for the 2011 academic year.

As a fall-back position, the polytechnic was discussing with the University of Otago leasing space temporarily in the Albany St buildings housing the former Phoenix Centre school for troubled teenagers.

The University purchased that site and a neighbouring property late last year.

allison.rudd@odt.co.nz

Completely missed the point

I think you've completely missed the point here. Sure, the stadium is way over budget and has put the DCC in a debt position where enormous rates increases are going to be the only way for the city to remain solvent.

If you lived in Dunedin I'm sure this would be an issue for you too.

However, at the same time the Mayor and the council have promised us this wonderful stadium they've signed off on a maximum price bid that doesn't include key items required for a functioning stadium: a scoreboard, turnstiles, turf, loos, many of the seats, the outfitting of the kitchens etc etc.

Any day now the penny will drop and we'll see the CST, cap in hand, begging for more money. I'm sure the council is praying that it wont happen before the election. We're going to need many unbudgeted millions to finish the thing.

I think we're just plain damned.

Equally, if you're a potential tenant, you'll need to provide anything other than the provided concrete shell. It's not surprising that, faced with an almost million dollar cost to build out any potential space, the Polytech has chosen to go elsewhere.

It's probably a wise move anyway. Imagine trying to be heard giving a lecture during a game, or trying to get past the drunken hoons to go to the toilets. It's just not a particularly attractive place to run a business from.

We do need to be charging at least enough rent to cover all of our costs and capital repayment, just like any other commercial entity. To do otherwise is to compete unfairly against private commercial landlords in the city.

 

Damned if you do, damned if you don't

This time last year the moaners were complaining about rental space being given away to cheaply.
Now they are moaning that we are charging too much?

Down the gurgler

Another potential stadium tenant down the gurgler. I understand the Dunedin North Macrame Club is looking for new premises.