Noisy student protesters disrupt Key's visit

Farewell gesture . . . A protester signals to Prime Minister John Key after the opening of the refurbished Robertson Library yesterday morning. Photo Gerard O'Brien
Farewell gesture . . . A protester signals to Prime Minister John Key after the opening of the refurbished Robertson Library yesterday morning. Photo Gerard O'Brien
A noisy demonstration from student protesters disrupted a visit by Prime Minister John Key to the Otago Polytechnic campus yesterday morning, when he officially opened the University of Otago's refurbished Robertson Library.

The rowdy reception from the more than 300 placard-waving and chanting protesters did not deter a relaxed Mr Key, who later accepted an "I love OUSA" T-shirt from student representatives inside the library.

The Otago University Students' Association organised yesterday's demonstration in protest at the Government's support of Act New Zealand's proposed Freedom of Association Bill, which threatens to remove compulsory membership of student associations.

The Bill, which had been stuck in procedural limbo because of delaying tactics by Opposition parties, came up for debate in Parliament on Wednesday - a move that was earlier than expected and upset student associations.

Mr Key acknowledged the "boisterous and warm welcome" he received.

The Robertson Library, which has been refurbished by the university at a cost of $10 million, was another example of the positive, university-inspired progress being made in Dunedin, Mr Key said.

"This university, in my view, is world-class. You are doing an outstanding job and this new development, alongside the [Forsyth Barr] stadium, are examples which speak volumes about the exciting progress, future and heart of Dunedin."

Police had moved to contain the crowd when Mr Key arrived, as protesters surged forward across Union St, but one rogue protester managed to get up close as Mr Key left the area.

Mr Key ignored the protesters during the visit and told the Otago Daily Times he would not meet the demonstrators.

"I don't think I'll talk to them, but we are happy to have to listen to their case and cause."

The impending legislation that the protesters were demonstrating against was "not our Bill, but we are supporting it", Mr Key said.

OUSA has been at the forefront of a nationwide campaign against the move to voluntary student membership, because it says it will undermine and cut existing student support services.

Mr Key said the Government would implement a levy, which universities could then use to secure fees from students to continue to fund existing association facilities and campus services.

He likened student associations to unions.

"From a tertiary perspective, this is the only sector in New Zealand's economy, at the moment, where unionism, for the most part, is compulsory. We want to put the education sector on the same footing as the rest of the country," he said.

OUSA president Logan Edgar said student associations were different from unions.

Dunedin police said there was no issue with the behaviour of the protesters, describing the action as an "orderly demonstration".

 

 

Student protest

I was there, observing the protest. It was peaceful and certainly not rowdy. The protestors were very well behaved and the police supervising the protest encountered no trouble with anyone in attendance.

Furthermore, Mr Key's itinerary for the day was not affected in the slightest by this demonstration, so I'm struggling to find any way that you can justify calling it "disruptive". 

Quite frankly, these people should be commended for standing up for a worthy cause in such a mature fashion.

[Abridged]

- Editor - The ODT stands by the story

Student protest

I am a liberal PhD Student and one of your "rowdies". The protest was peaceful and police did not have to make big efforts to "contain" the crowd. The "noise" was quiet enough for John Key to give an interview inside the library, which was screened in the news of
Channel1 yesterday night.

When he was inside the building he also agreed to speak to the protesting students, but when exiting he swiftly walked to his car.

While waiting on the Prime Minister, the disappointed students expressed their opinion by chanting e.g. "hey hey ho ho, VSM has got to go",  and waving placards concerned about the future of student services, e.g. Radio1 and Student Support.

I have to add that your selection of pictures is misleading as well. It was a peaceful democratic event. Channel 9's coverage of the events shows a more accurate picture:

ODT also misses the point why VSM is harmful to student life, e.g. poorer students might not have the freedom to choose within a VSM environment. The new regulation would be only
convenient for some but very harmful for the most. Comparing student associations with unions is nothing but an imprecise rhetorical argument.

Sincerely,

Thomas Koentges

[Abridged]

Editor - The ODT stands by the story. It was John Key who compared student associations with unions.