Maori MP applauds Dunedin school's leadership, courage

The Maori flag flying at North East Valeey Normal school in Dunedin. Photo by Stephen Jaquiery.
The Maori flag flying at North East Valeey Normal school in Dunedin. Photo by Stephen Jaquiery.
A Maori Party MP has weighed in over the forwarding of a racially offensive email to a Dunedin school, saying negative attitudes towards Maori are stronger in the South Island.

Te Tai Tonga MP Rahui Katene said she received "pretty extreme reactions" when she drove vehicles with the Maori Party and tino rangatiratanga flags.

"In fact, I have recently lost my tino rangatiratanga flag: broken off by a passerby one night in Nelson - in my own home town, outside my brother's house.

"In Te Waipounamu, negative attitudes towards Maori and Maori issues are much stronger than in the north," Mrs Katene said.

Yesterday, the Otago Daily Times reported Dunedin businessman Geoff Portman forwarded the email "I wish I was a Maori" to the school, after becoming incensed over its decision to fly "so-call Maori flags".

Mrs Katene said his decision was unfortunate, and she congratulated the school for "showing leadership and courage in flying flags that represent the diversity within the school".

"To grow as a nation, New Zealand and New Zealanders need to get beyond the ignorance and slogans `one nation, one New Zealand, one flag, one people' and realise that we are a nation of two peoples, with many other ethnicities living here. We will only mature as a nation when we learn to celebrate our differences rather than denigrate them."

It was regrettable such negative issues shown in the media during the Rugby World Cup, as "the whole world is watching us".

The email in question was forwarded to Mr Portman by an acquaintance at Orion Crop Protection, which distanced itself from the controversial contents. These included, "You rob us, convert our cars, rape our women and bash our elderly".

General manager Murray Hern said his company in no way endorsed the email.

"The individual advised me that he received the email and thought the content was ridiculous. He forwarded it to an individual outside our organisation - which in hindsight was a mistake."

Mr Hern said the email had circulated widely and his employee found himself "linked with a message that expresses views that he did not write and he does not support".

He confirmed the man had been reprimanded.

Also becoming involved with the issue was Race Relations Conciliator Joris de Bres, who said the email was first referred to him in August and "it is a pretty distasteful and misleading kind of document".

The email had crossed his desk a number of times, forwarded from people working at "reputable businesses and organisations".

While the email was "provocative and offensive, and misleading", it was not unlawful.

"These things have a circulation and have a readership ... I am disturbed it gets sent to a school and sent by people in reputable and professional businesses."

hamish.mcneilly@odt.co.nz

Tangata Whenua?

I have to say I am getting a little tired of this "tangata whenua" bizzo.  Correct me if I'm wrong, but does not "tangata whenua" translate as "people of the land", ie "indigenous".  If that's the case, I must point out, as I'm sure others must have before me, that the Maori people are no more indigenous to this country than the rest of us - whether we be English, Scottish, French, Spanish, Polish, German, Italian, South African, Greek, whatever ... Maori were settlers here themselves - maybe a few hundred years earlier than the rest of us but, taking the big picture into account, that's pretty much just yesterday.

You've made a twit of yourself

Completely agree with Juju1967, could not put it better. The more widely all people of NZ are educated on our shared histories as well as our distinct & individual histories, the better. I'd rather celebrate all & every aspect of being a New Zealander than insist on one nation, one flag.

I'd like to see a bit of introspection from Geoff Portman & an apology once he realises what a twit he has made of himself.

One nation, many people, tonnes of flags?

I didn't know "One Nation, One People, One Flag" was an ignorant attitude to have ... If we are a nation of many ethnicities then surly we are a nation of many people not just two - Maori and New Zealanders. My personal opinion is that the Maori flag is divisive and I'd be very vocal if my kids' school decided to fly it.

Shame on you

Pandering schmandering. As "tauiwi" ie some who is not Maori, I have no issue with the showing of one flag - the Maori flag. And I applaud the NEV Primary School for showing they are prepared to show they understand the place of Maori as Tangata Whenua. To fly the Maori Flag as they have does not happen without insight and discussion. It has been a symbol of division in the past BUT more recently as we understand our place here in Aotearoa and Otepoti, it has been for many Tauiwi become a symbol of hope and unity.

You obviously missed that lesson at school and perhaps need to enrol at NEV to learn something.

Well done NEV Primary - gotta get me a FLAG too. 

 

Showing one flag

How is showing the Maori flag reflecting our diversity? To show diversity would require flags and symbols from all our cultural backgrounds. 

All it shows is that they are pandering to the Maori.

Shame on NEV school for displaying bias.

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Laser Electrical MiltonMiltonFarm Machinery
Up HairDunedinHairdressers
I Love ParisDunedinFootwear
Rialto CinemasDunedinCinemas