Caversham tunnel vision could cost $1.6m

Gerard Hyland with his bike at the entry to the old Caversham railway tunnel. Photo by Jane Dawber.
Gerard Hyland with his bike at the entry to the old Caversham railway tunnel. Photo by Jane Dawber.
The Dunedin Tunnels Trail Trust is facing a $1.6 million hurdle in its quest to reopen the old Caversham tunnel to cyclists.

A draft budget prepared by council staff for this week's council pre-draft budget meetings showed work to make the tunnel safe for public use could cost $1.689 million.

That was the estimated maximum cost of the four-stage project, based on the council's contractor rates.

However, trust member Gerard Hyland was confident fundraising by the trust, volunteer labour and other in-kind offers of support would significantly reduce the bill.

The draft budget was included in a council staff report prepared for councillors on the proposed southern cycleway, which would run from Mosgiel to Dunedin's city centre via the tunnel.

The first two stages of the project would include formalising the relationship between the council and the trust, and protecting electrical cables and a gas pipeline within the tunnel, at a total cost of $326,000.

The bulk of the costs, totalling $1.338 million, would come in stages three and four, and it would be left to the trust and any partners to raise the money, the budget shows.

Work in stage three would cost $828,000 and include protection of a council wastewater pipe running through the tunnel ($320,000) and the installation of atmospheric monitoring equipment ($400,000), if required.

Further "optional enhancements" could also come in stage four, including CCTV and lighting, a ramp at the Burnside end of the tunnel and a path from Sydney Park, together costing $510,000.

The report by council transportation planning manager Sarah Connolly recommended the project be included in the council's long-term plan, but made no recommendation on funding the bulk of the costs.

Her report noted there was money for the project in the council's budget, with $150,000 of $158,000 allocated for initial investigation work still unspent.

Ms Connolly told the ODT initial project management work had been conducted in-house, and a council working party looking at the project had negotiated significantly reduced rates for geotechnical and gas-monitoring work inside the tunnel.

Her report recommended the remaining $150,000 be used to help fund the early stages of the tunnel project.

Mr Hyland told the ODT the council's cost estimates were "surprisingly high", but he was confident the trust could complete the work.

"We would be doing the same work, or similar work, but in-kind, so we wouldn't get anywhere near that sort of cost level."

He hoped the tunnel's gates would be opened to volunteer workers and others to enter "at their own risk" by October, in time for the 140th anniversary of the tunnel's construction.

- chris.morris@odt.co.nz

 

User pays a misnomer.

@ Keithmcc, this project IS for kids and most families.  The 'enthusiasts' already power up and down the hills: areas that are too steep / dangerous for a family to go biking. 

As for 'user pays', each kilometre cycled actually adds to the city coffers. Check the research done by Transit.

 

Is there evidence?

Is there evidence indicating that "atmospheric
monitoring equipment ($400,000), if required (as reported)" is likely to be required?  

User pays?

If we are going to tax cyclists then how about a footpath tax. Most pedestrians use a footpath and don't want to have to pay tax towards it. We could put a tax on the sale of running shoes.

How stupid is this plan to take more cars off the roads. We would end up with less pollution, less wear an tear on the roads, less congestion... what a crazy world that would be!

User pays

It will be interesting to see if the noisy minority that use bikes will, just for once, actually dip into their pockets and pay for the infrastructure they want. Fundraising is NOT just belly-aching to goverments at all levels and demanding handouts.

Bike riders don't want to pay registration or licence fees, so how about a "tax" on the sale of lycra riding suits and high-end bikes?  At least then kids and most families will not be penalised, but the "enthusiasts" can pay their way.

What confusion?

Electrical cables, gas pipelines and wastewater pipes are all different.  That said, beats me why they can't 'protect' them all at the same time.

 

 

Spending

They just keep spending. Why not pay off some of the stadium?

The $1.6m illusion

Challispoint - the $1.6m being quoted is likely to be far greater than the likely cost, and certainly much more than is needed to get the tunnel reopened and usable again.

- installation of atmospheric
monitoring equipment ($400,000), if required.

Further "optional enhancements"could also come in stage
four, including CCTV and lighting, a ramp at the Burnside end
of the tunnel and a path from Sydney Park, together costing
$510,000.

Deducting them cuts it to $0.7m for a start, and the rest of the costs are maximum and should be able to be done for much less. And the way the article is written it looks like the same $320,000 is included in two stages.

It could be argued that protecting the pipe and cables should have been done anyway, instead of spending money on installing gates.

Why so expensive?

I do wonder why it costs $1.6m for a short length of cycleway, when the entire Alexandra to Roxburgh project is only $3.3m.  It does seem that DCC staff quote high prices when they don't want a project to proceed but low costs when they are in favour. 

Tunnel cost confusion

It looks like cable and pipeline protection is included in two separate stages:

"The first two stages of the project would include...protecting electrical cables and a gas pipeline within the
tunnel, at a total cost of $326,000."

"Work in stage three would cost $828,000 and include
protection of a council wastewater pipe running through the
tunnel ($320,000) "

Is this a double up of cost or an error?

 

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Cardrona Ski ResortWanakaRecreational Activities
Cromwell TransportCromwellTransport & Haulage
Jons Retail MeatsDunedinButchers
Dunedin City New LifeDunedinChurches