Jim Quinn
KiwiRail's controversial decision to have its new freight
wagons made in China may have backfired.
KiwiRail has conceded that nearly 10% of the new Chinese-made
flat top wagons are already out of commission, with 44 of the
500 wagons undergoing repairs or maintenance.
The state-owned enterprise was criticised last year, after
its decision to award the $49 million contract to the China
CNR Corporation, rather than have them built at its workshops
in Dunedin and Lower Hutt, contributed to 44 workers being
made redundant at the Hillside workshop.
Most of the wagons were out of commission because of a "wheel
slip issue", KiwiRail chief executive Jim Quinn said.
He said KiwiRail planned for around 5% of the wagon fleet to
be undergoing maintenance or repair and that the situation
was "not that far from normal".
"If you remove those wagons, we just have a standard number
of what we would expect to be under maintenance at any one
time. Two-thirds of the ones that we have built in New
Zealand have exactly the same issue," Mr Quinn said.
However, Dunedin South MP Clare Curran said the news was "no
surprise".
"There are question marks around the quality of the steel and
the build and that's just a fact," she said yesterday.
"I'm very sceptical of the figures that KiwiRail have been
providing. I think they have had a deliberate strategy to
build them overseas and I'd like to see some independent
figures and an independent evaluation of the process."
KiwiRail had estimated it would cost around 25% more to build
the wagons in New Zealand, but both the figure and process
were dismissed by the Rail and Maritime Transport Union
yesterday.
"KiwiRail will inevitably have whole-of-life cost blowouts if
it continues to take a short-term procurement approach solely
focused on the cheapest products available," RMTU general
secretary Wayne Butson said.
"Value is not just money, nor is it just the purchase price.
It is also about ongoing repairs and maintenance work, as
KiwiRail are finding out, not to mention the primary and
secondary jobs that are created and industries supported when
goods are manufactured locally."
Mr Butson said construction of the 500 wagons would have been
"an easily achievable target" for the Dunedin and Lower Hutt
workshops.
"Instead the company sent the work overseas and 44 workers in
Dunedin lost their jobs."
nigel.benson@odt.co.nz
A name, residential address, and (preferably residential) telephone number is required from readers who comment on ODT Online. These details will not be visible to site visitors.