DCC's credit rating up

Dave Cull.
Dave Cull.
Dunedin city councillors burst into applause as it was confirmed yesterday international credit agency Standard and Poor's had lifted its negative outlook for the Dunedin City Council.

The news - delivered part-way through yesterday's full council meeting - also left Mayor Dave Cull claiming vindication despite his critics.

''I think what this does is vindicate the last council's resolution and determination and the effectiveness of what we set out to do,'' he told the Otago Daily Times.

''It worked.''

His comments came after S&P, in a statement yesterday, announced it had lifted its rating outlook for the council - as well as subsidiary company Dunedin City Treasury Ltd - from negative to stable.

Both entities retained their ''AA'' long-term, and ''A-1+'' short-term, credit ratings.

The news was hand-delivered to Mr Cull part-way through yesterday's full council meeting by a smiling council chief executive Dr Sue Bidrose, prompting Mr Cull to interrupt the meeting to make the announcement.

Councillors responded with quiet whoops of delight and applause as Cr Richard Thomson, the council's finance committee chairman, praised staff for the ''extraordinary turnaround''.

S&P credit analyst Anthony Walker said in the statement the decision reflected the council's ''significantly'' improved budget performance and liquidity over the past year.

''We expect these improvements to be sustained, allowing Dunedin to reduce its debt burden,'' he said.

Mr Cull, speaking after the meeting, told the ODT the change was a ''testament'' to the good work of the previous council and council staff under former chief executive Paul Orders.

''I think he [Mr Orders] can take a fair bit of credit, but he was working under the direction of the last council, who not only reformed DCHL governance, but set quite tough targets for rates rises, debt containment and acceleration [of repayments].''

It was also a vote of confidence in the new council and its new chief executive, as S&P staff - who visited the city late last month - had to be convinced the turnaround could be sustained, he said.

''I think that they have expressed confidence that this council is resolute and on target.''

He expected the change would result in savings for the council when it came to rolling over existing loans.

''If you're upgraded, you're a better risk for people lending you money, so it must be an advantage.

''We're not looking for new debt now, but we do have to roll over existing debt from time to time, and as we come off one interest rate, the new interest rate you achieve will be determined by the risk that you present.''

The change came just over a year after the agency shifted the council to a negative outlook, saying there was a one-in-three chance of a credit downgrade within the next two years.

That was based on S&P's view Dunedin might not achieve its financial targets, outlined in its long-term plan, and had ''limited room to manoeuvre'' within budgets.

Yesterday's statement acknowledged the council's work to restructure its senior management and company boards while focusing on finding efficiencies and reducing non-essential capital expenditure.

The work had resulted in ''substantial turnaround'' for the council this year, and the likelihood of ''significant adverse findings'' from the Auditor-general's inquiry into land purchases by Delta was also considered low, S&P said.

However, the council's strengths were still partially offset by its high debt ''relative to international peers'', moderate budget flexibility and S&P's ''neutral view'' of the city's economy, it said.

The rating could also be lowered again with any future change in policy direction, operating or capital expenditure, or if debt levels approached 180% of operating revenues, S&P warned.

A copy of S&P's full report is expected to be released in about a week.


Credit rating up, rates up

We are so pleased, this means we can spend millions more on loss making ventures to add to are already ballooning debt. Rates are still rising at more than twice the rate of inflation year on year, businesses are closing, retail is on its knees, unemployment is at 20 year highs, and Dunedin is the worst performing main centre in the country. In the mean time our Council bursts into collective applause because S&P says we are worthy of obtaining yet more credit. This seems to be about the only thing Mayor Cull can find to celebrate, rate payers can look forward to yet more rate increases as young people leave Dunedin and economic growth stays stagnant. What a farce!

Credit rating up/down

S&P did not revise the credit rating up, it moved from being under negative credit watch to stable. Its rating band stayed the same. I'm at a loss to see what the excitement is about. The fact the council can enforce rates and make increases to its ratepayer base is the only reason S&P would have any confidence in the city.   


Always patting themselves on the back.  Who cares? Our rates are going through the roof.

Get a grip. Standards and Poor - who are these faceless people? 

Be careful

Just because they didn't drop the city's credit ratings doesn't mean that the city council should suddenly go crazy and start borrowing again - our debt burden is still many times higher than it has ever been, and that debt still needs to be paid.

Borrowing more money would mean more interest and principal to be paid, as a result rates will go up - let's wait until rates have gone back down to where they were were before we start borrowing again.

Who cares

Whoop te do break out the streamers and fireworks we are still in a truckload of debt this makes no difference to the ratepayer.


ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Aquapaintz DirectDunedinRoofers
Tim Hawkins Central Lakes PhotographyBannockburnPhotographers
N.Z Modern School of MusicDunedinTraining & Education
Switch AccountingDunedinAccountants