DCC manager terminates vending deal

Tony Avery
Tony Avery
A Dunedin City Council manager has walked away from his own contract to restock vending machines at Moana Pool, as an investigation into a possible conflict of interest continues, it has been confirmed.

Council aquatic services manager Steve Prescott decided to terminate the contract with Vending Direct Ltd - owner of four of the pool's eight vending machines - last week, it was confirmed yesterday.

That was weeks after it emerged Mr Prescott had been receiving up to $10,000 a year to restock the machines, despite previous denials by the council any of its staff were profiting from the machines.

The sudden cancellation of Mr Prescott's contract with Vending Direct took place last Friday, with immediate effect, but only came to light yesterday.

Information released by council infrastructure and networks general manager Tony Avery on Wednesday had stated Mr Prescott still held the contract.

That prompted Vending Direct managing director Paul Faint to contact the Otago Daily Times yesterday to say that was not correct.

He would not elaborate, but Mr Avery confirmed when contacted the cancellation of the contract had been omitted from information released on Wednesday.

''What we should have done in the release [on Wednesday] is add that it has been terminated as of, I think, last Friday.''

The contract was due to expire in January, anyway, but Mr Prescott had decided to do so immediately, given recent media attention, Mr Avery said.

''He's just made a decision that it's just not worth it.''

Asked if Mr Prescott had been told to make the decision, Mr Avery said: ''We had a discussion about lots of aspects to do with the vending machines.

''At the end of the day it was his call.''

Mr Prescott could not be contacted yesterday, but it was understood he had been told not to talk to the media.

Mr Avery said the council, which was not a party to the contract, would not face any financial penalty from the early and immediate termination of the deal.

He could not say if that was also true for Mr Prescott or his company, Prescott Enterprises.

''I don't know the details of the contractual arrangements that Prescott Enterprises had with Vending Direct.''

The machines were still operational and Vending Direct was understood to have made alternative arrangements, Mr Avery said.

The latest development came after independent auditing firm Crowe Horwath, which has an office in Dunedin, was called in to scrutinise the contractual arrangements surrounding the machines.

The investigation was expected to be completed within two weeks, and would include looking at whether Mr Prescott had a conflict of interest, it was confirmed this week.

Mr Prescott was in charge of negotiating and renewing contracts to keep the machines at Moana Pool, while at the same time profiting from his own contract to restock them.

However, Mr Avery said the council did not yet have a view on whether Mr Prescott had a conflict of interest arising from the deal.

- chris.morris@odt.co.nz


Concern to Council

Dunners: Sorry, but you're wrong. It should be of concern to council. 

Conflict of interest

Sounds to me like a conflict of interest.

I was at the pool today and they take up a lot of the foyer space. My question is: 'Why have them at all?'   Most of the stuff is sugar++ and non nutritional. I saw tiny kids going up to one and saying 'I want that and that". 

What do we (ratepayers/users) gain by having them there?  

Couldn't agree more

pcObelix, you have it spot on in my opinion.

The contract is not even a Council contract, it's between the vending machine owner and a third party, in this case Steve Prescott.  It was never a contract under Councils control.  The vending machine owners can contract who they like to stock the machines, it's of no concern to Council whatsoever.

It is a witch hunt 100%, just the kind of story the ODT likes to get its teeth into.


Witch Hunt

Seriously.....I think this has ended up been blown out of all proportion.  

An absolute witch hunt here by a disgruntled party that did not get what they wanted....so what do you do when you do not get what you want...you go running to the press, and have them make a huge issue out of something that seems in my opinion to be fairly minor.



GJ Philip: Here is an apparently well-run council with Dr this and Professor that collecting 6 figure sums to bask in their own glory, whilst issuing grandiose press statements, and disestablishing jobs, but they can't even form an opinion on the conflict of interest about a public official who negotiates a third-party contract that rewards his own company!


ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Oamakau Auto CentreYour TownService Stations
Macandrew Bay PharmacyDunedinPharmacies
Online WorksWanakaMarketing Services
Milburn and Neill OptometristsDunedinOptometrists