Talks on hotel bid ongoing

Dave Cull.
Dave Cull.
The  fate of Dunedin's proposed $100 million waterfront hotel hangs in the balance, but a decision on whether to proceed - or abandon the project - could be just weeks away, it has been confirmed.

Dunedin Mayor Dave Cull told the Otago Daily Times all parties were working to address ''complex'' issues but he could offer no guarantees a way forward could be found.

''I'm keeping all my options open. I don't think there's any guarantees anywhere,'' he said when contacted yesterday.

Mr Cull's comments came as he confirmed two further meetings with the developers - Queenstown-based Jing Song and her husband, Chinese construction company owner Ping Cao - had taken place in recent months.

The most recent was in Auckland on December 4, when Mr Cull and the developers had initial talks about the ways traffic, noise, pedestrian access and other issues arising - if the hotel was built at 41 Wharf St - could be addressed.

Proposed solutions were also on the table, but no agreement had been reached, and Mr Cull said he could not elaborate.

''Frankly, we're still working through them because they're complex and many.''

However, Mr Cull expected the developers would be in a position to ''come to some conclusions'' within the next month or so.

That could mean reaching agreement on the process to follow to advance the project, which could lead to a fresh consent application, a plan change process or some other mechanism, he said.

Alternatively, the developers could conclude the project was unworkable at 41 Wharf St, and would then have to decide whether to consider other sites or to abandon their plans altogether, he said.

''All of those are possibilities.''

The plans for the 27-storey hotel and apartment tower on the city's waterfront were unveiled by Betterways Advisory Ltd director Steve Rodgers, a Dunedin lawyer, in May 2012. The council's hearings committee opted to decline consent after considering 507 submissions.

Betterways has since appealed the decision to the Environment Court, although the parties were continuing to discuss solutions.

Ms Song could not be contacted yesterday and Mr Rodgers would only say there were no new developments to report.

Mr Cull met the developers in Auckland on October 16 to consider the results of independent planning advice, offered by the council immediately after the decision was announced.

Yesterday, he said all parties hoped for a speedy conclusion to the talks.

''I'm pretty sure that Ping and Jing and the developers want some conclusions too ... they don't want to be still working through this in six months' or a year's time.''

An apartment building

Let's be clear - this is not a "hotel", it's an apartment  building with a hotel attached in order to try and sneak it past the council and get it built - it has more apartment accommodation than it does hotel space - let's treat it as we would any apartment building and use the same zoning rules we would for a similar building.

Hands off, Dave

What concerns me the most from the published article is the revelation that the Mayor is involving himself in discussions around consent applications and potential changes to the District Plan. Aside from the fact that he is completely unqualified to do so (unless he has recently completed a degree in resource management or town planning), any process invloving a consent application or plan change is an internal matter for the DCC and should not be influenced in any way by a political appointee. Granting of a consent, or the potential changing of a District Plan in order to accomodate a single applicant, can have major repercussions for the city that an unqualified person in a position of power does not have the necessary skills to anticipate.
The process exists for a reason.

I would be happy if

They took their twinkle and shoved it somewhere else, far away.

Good architecture

All I ask is for good architecture, appropriate for site.  

If it is to dominate the city it had better be an outstanding design 

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
The Kensington Tui ClubroomsDunedinTaverns
Lorraine Lea LinenDunedinHomeware
Macaulay MotorsQueenstownCar Sales
KLP Builders Ltd.DunedinBuilders