Cities vie for big oil's favour

Port Otago's deep-water harbour is an advantage touted by local business leaders attempting to court fossil fuel giants but Invercargill's SouthPort has commissioned a study comparing the two ports as part of its bid. Photo by Brenda Harwood.
Port Otago's deep-water harbour is an advantage touted by local business leaders attempting to court fossil fuel giants but Invercargill's SouthPort has commissioned a study comparing the two ports as part of its bid. Photo by Brenda Harwood.
Dunedin and Invercargill have both been courting big oil companies in recent years for the chance of a billion-dollar bonanza from potential gas deposits in the Great South Basin. The Star looks at both centres to see who might win the ultimate prize - the base for southern gas drilling.

Insiders believe Dunedin's proximity to promising gas fields in the Great South Basin should see it become a base for any largescale production - but it is not a done deal yet.

Further south, the Southland Energy Consortium of 193 companies has been focused on the issue for the past seven years, with some even taking on work off-shore to gain experience.

Shell New Zealand chairman Rob Jager said no decision had been made on where to set up a base should exploration - scheduled to take place in two years - lead to full production.

Anadarko will use Dunedin as a base during its exploration, which begins in a few weeks but, if exploration is successful, full production will not begin for five to 10 years.

Venture Southland manager Steve Canny said distance was a major factor in choosing a base but not the only one.

He said if the best gas deposits were found at the southern end of the prospecting area, Invercargill could make a more economic base.

Southland had a port with generous ''lay off'' facilities (space for long-term storage), the third longest airport runway in the country, quality accommodation and a co-ordinated manufacturing sector, Mr Canny said.

He said many Southland companies had been getting involved in oil and gas projects in Taranaki and overseas to gain the skills to support the industry in the south.

SouthPort New Zealand in Bluff has been pushing its case strongly with the oil and gas companies, highlighting its modern facilities and ''lay-off'' space for the massive quantity of gear required.

South Port NZ chief executive Mark O'Connor confirmed a study comparing South Port with Port Otago had been done by the consortium but he would not provide it to The Star.

''We would rather promote those advantages directly to the exploration parties.''

Mr Canny said a gas industry in the lower south would benefit both regions and it was important local engineers and support industries were up to speed on what was required.

''It doesn't matter how aware of the opportunity they are it won't exist unless they have certification and skills that are necessary.''

Mr Jager said Taranaki's economy had increased 46.9% between 2007 and 2010, largely due to oil and gas production.

Dunedin City Council's economic development unit manager Des Adamson said even if processing was done on factory ships off-shore, up to 1000 local workers would still be needed.

He said Shell and Anadarko had done their homework and were ''well aware of the capability that exists in Dunedin and Invercargill''.

''Generally speaking they will go to the port that is the most economic.''

The DCC development unit, local businesses and the port had done a lot of work determining the requirements of the large drilling companies.

''When was the last time we had an opportunity like this in the city?'' Mr Adamson said.

Factors in Dunedin's favour included the port, marine and heavy engineering industries, regular flights from Dunedin to Australia and a tertiary-level hospital, Mr Adamson said.

Port Otago commercial manager Peter Brown said Port Otago was the deepest container port in the country and could easily cater for the ships used in the oil and gas sector.

The port had more than 20ha of lay-off space and had identified areas that could be used for storage by an off-shore gas industry.

Mayor Dave Cull said the DCC had been preparing for oil and gas exploration for as long as Invercargill but there were still a lot of unknowns.

Re-zoning harbourside areas had been scaled back to make sure there was enough space for the energy companies to set up there if required.

''What Shell particularly have said - they were at pains to say - don't go making any plans or expecting any big changes or booms for a while,'' he said.

He said it would not be wise of any council to invest large amounts of money without knowing what was needed and where.

Otago Chamber of Commerce chief executive John Christie said Dunedin was well-placed to take advantage of any economic opportunities from gas exploration.

He did not want to get into an ''us-against-them type of situation'' because both regions would benefit from the industry.

Oil Free Southland

I'm a Southlander - we're here and we're vocal. We are worried about the push to drill at extreme depths. More than a few of us have grave fears for the region's economy if this gamble goes ahead. So no, don't assume the welcome mat is out in Invers.

Money is everything

National govt has turned NZ into a money grubbing cartoon character. NZ should be ashamed of giving away its environment or sovereignty in the name of making a quick buck. Surely there are better ways to earn income than succumbing to big corrupt corporations and foreign governments (TPPA), etc. I don't like what I'm seeing lately. Oh well, carry on drooling over dollar signs, as it's all that matters now isn't it? I'm starting to wonder what wouldn't NZ do for "economic benefits"?

There's no bias


There is no bias from the media on this issue, on the contrary, I think the ODT has given the anti-progress and anti-prosperity brigade more than enough media coverage.

Maybe if the greenies didn't scaremonger and lie about what is actually happening, they'd be taken more seriously. You can't protest against something you use and you can't keep using anti-oil as slogan when it's natural gas, which is greener and cleaner for the environment. You guys should be all for it.

The people of Dunedin and Otago as a whole aren't stupid, they see through the lies, half-baked conspiracy theories and want a better future for them and their children and grandchildren.


Welcome to Otago Anadarko!

I don't see many Southlanders writing to complain about the possibility of drilling for oil and gas in their backyard. On the contrary they are excited and will welcome them with open arms because they can see that the benefits far outweigh the risks.


Pro oil

The fourth pro-oil article in two weeks versus 1 questioning article. Methinks the media is biased. Ok Dunedin. If that's what you want, become just another big dirty port city. It's not going to encourage your people to stay. If and when it does come on line, most of those promoting it will be retired. Perhaps they will move to Florida. That disaster might just about be fixed by then. It's only by crisis we ever learn. Instead of being on the cutting edge of future development away from oil, we will be seen as the last bastion of dirty big oil. Poor old NZ. From all those firsts we used to have to the little country at the ar.. end of the world that couldn't think for itself. Bet the Texans and Dutch are laughing all the way. "Ha ha. They still believe in the trickle down effect".

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Clyde Holiday & Sporting ComplexClydeHoliday Parks
Central Chilled FreightDunedinTransport & Haulage
Alpine Choppers LtdQueenstownHelicopter & Aeroplane Flights
Newton and Sykes 2005 LtdDunedinPaint & Panel