Council may net $10m in sales

Robert Clark.
Robert Clark.
The Dunedin City Council plans to sell surplus land and property over the next two to three years in a move expected to raise about $10 million.

About 150 surplus parcels of land and property to be offered are expected to bring at least $5 million.

Several bigger pieces of property, including surplus land at Logan Park and the Caledonian Bowling Club in Andersons Bay Rd, are also scheduled for sale in the same period and are expected to bring in about another $5 million.

Council economic development and property group manager Robert Clark discussed the plan with councillors this week during annual plan discussions, putting his case for employing a staff member to run the sale process.

Mr Clark said a survey of property used by all council departments was done about a year ago and surplus property identified.

It was mainly land and included leftover areas of property bought to widen roads or unneeded land at the edge of reservoirs.

Some property was difficult to value because of its size or location, and the biggest piece might be worth several hundred thousand dollars.

A list of the properties would not be made public because of commercial sensitivities, but any potentially contentious sales would be brought to the council first.

One or two properties had already been sold, but selling properties in earnest would start within the next few months, once a person was employed to look after the process.

Councillors wanted to know why a salesperson was needed when the council already worked with real estate agents.

Mr Clark told them real estate agents were not necessarily interested in the best deal for the council - more in securing their commission.

There were also legislative issues around some of the property better dealt with by a person with specialist skills.

Asked by Cr Richard Thomson why no revenue from sales was included in draft budgets presented to councillors, Mr Clark said it was not wise to include revenue from sales in budgets when there was no guarantee when sales would be completed.

The sale to Ngai Tahu of a piece of surplus land at Logan Park, for example, required public consultation and various consents to be in place first.

While he was ''very positive'' the sale was going to happen, it would be wrong to budget to get $2 million, because it might or might not happen in a certain year.

He confirmed to deputy mayor Chris Staynes any revenue from the sale of surplus land and property would go towards debt reduction.

Cr David Benson-Pope asked if council-controlled companies were going through the same process, and was told by chief executive Dr Sue Bidrose it was one of the matters the council's new group chief financial officer, Grant McKenzie, would raise.

To a question from Cr Lee Vandervis, Mr Clark said he would still like to build up the council's property portfolio because of the potentially significant financial gains it offered, but that was ''on the back-burner'' because the council was ''not allowed'' to raise debt, only repay it.

Cr John Bezett told Mr Clark if he believed it would benefit the council, he should bring a report to councillors.

Mr Clark said a plan had been written in conjunction with PricewaterhouseCoopers, which prompted Cr Thomson to ask Mr Clark if he saw the council as a property investment company.

Mr Clark said his job was to invest in property on the council's behalf.

Dr Bidrose then intervened to make it clear more property investment was not an option for the council at this stage.

''There is clarity that borrowing money for property investment, until we reach the financial strategy top target of $200 million debt, is highly unlikely to be something we put to [the council] as a priority.''

Cr Thomson replied: ''My personal view is it should never be put to us as a priority, because we are not a property investment company.''

Consumed by the stadium

MDownes: You make a good point about the futility of the DCC trying to sell land and buildings. Over two or three years they expect to raise $10 million, but the Financial Blackhole Stadium consumes this amount even faster than you think. The DCC doesn't want you to know the annual total stadium losses and costs to the city, so they have never provided a total figure which includes the operating losses of both stadium companies as well as the subsidies and the cost of interest on the DCC held debt. A recent calculation shows this to be about $18 million each year ($49,000 per day).

The $10 million from the property sales will be enough to keep the stadium going for 29 weeks (6½ months). If it takes three years to sell the properties, then over that time the FB Stadium will have consumed $54 million.

It is not exaggerating to call this a financial disaster. By not admitting the true size of the problem, the staff of the DCC are showing us that they can not be trusted. It is time for the new Chief Executive to come clean and reveal the official figure for the total ratepayer impact.

One more time, folks

Hype O. Thermia is onto it once again.

I can just see them saying in a few months time "We didn't raise as much as we thought".

Surely the Carisbrook and Wall Street debacles, amongst others, has amply demonstrated that the DCC is very poor property manager.

Shhh, we've got something to sell

A list of the properties would not be made public because of commercial sensitivities.  

Strange sales strategy, keeping the list of goods for sale a secret from prospective buyers.  Or is it, make this information available only to those special people who are sometimes called "stakeholders", worthy of more consultation than the common ratepayer alias mushroom?

Council revenue

The money raised from these sales is the equivalent to what is being gobbled up by the stadium every 12 months. It really does put things into perspective. The financial decline of Dunedin continues...

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Elders Real Estate Ltd Licensed REAA 2008 Ltd (Mosgiel)MosgielReal Estate Agents
Happy Valley B&BMoerakiBed & Breakfasts
Humes Pipeline SystemsDunedinFarming Supplies
Fort Enfield TavernOamaruTaverns