Dunedin boy to undergo experimental treatment

Caleb Turner (2) is off to the United States and Mexico for stem cell therapy for cerebral palsy seizures, accompanied by his parents, Lindsay and Shirley Turner. Photo by Jane Dawber.
Caleb Turner (2) is off to the United States and Mexico for stem cell therapy for cerebral palsy seizures, accompanied by his parents, Lindsay and Shirley Turner. Photo by Jane Dawber.
A Dunedin mother wants to give her 2-year-old son the chance of a better life by taking him to the United States and Mexico for an umbilical cord stem cell transplant.

Shirley Turner said her son, Caleb, had cerebral palsy, for which there was no cure.

However, a US-based doctor had been having a lot of success with stem cell transplants and all those who had undergone the procedure had gained something from it, Mrs Turner said.

Caleb could have up to 50 seizures a day as a result of his severe cerebral palsy, and those were just the ones she saw, she said.

Caleb cannot walk, talk, or even roll over and sometimes he chokes while he is eating.

The outcome of the $15,000 transplant, which will use stem cells from donated umbilical cord blood, was unknown, but at worst it would do no harm, Mrs Turner said.

"The thing I'm really hoping is it will stop his seizures. Anything after that would be a bonus.

"Children who have had it done in the US have all improved and had a better quality of life."

Doctors have told her if Caleb was still having seizures by the end of the year, he was likely to suffer more brain damage.

"Time is not on our side anymore. If we don't have enough money we will have to take out a loan and keep fundraising when we get back."

She has estimated the trip would cost the family $35,000-$40,000, and they planned to spend the next six weeks before they leave fundraising.

Cerebral Palsy Society of New Zealand general manager Harvey Brunt said early indications were that the treatment could make a significant difference, but that was not yet backed up by research.

"It could be very exciting."

A large cerebral palsy conference was being held in Sydney next year and he was looking forward to hearing what developments there had been in treatments for the disorder.

Dr Jim Faed, haematologist and acting head of pathology at the University of Otago, said a lot of research was under way into the use of stem cells.

"It is still very much an experimental treatment. I fully understand parents wanting the best for their children, but at this time we can't say what the best will be. It is still a very grey area."

Umbilical cord stem cells were considered adult stem cells and were unrelated to embryonic stem cells, Dr Faed said.

Caleb developed cerebral palsy after suffering a massive brain bleed just days after birth.

Nobody knew whether he would survive but as it turned out Caleb "was a wee battler", Mrs Turner said.

During his first year of life he had seven brain operations to relieve pressure on his brain due to a build-up of fluid.

The cerebral palsy society estimates about 7000 people in New Zealand have some degree of cerebral palsy, ranging from mild to severe. It does not get worse with age.

 

Experimental stem cells.....

While they have so much potential I think we need to exercise some caution, particularly when the treatment is to be used on vulnerable groups like children. We already have the case of Willie Terpstra who went to China for one of these therapies, with any initial improve being short lived and her dying later the same year. I also do not have any faith that there is no risk even if it doesn't help up until more research is done and the current problems solved - a recent report in the medical literature shows a 13 year old boy who developed brain and spine tumours 4 years after treatment with stem cells. The report is: Donor-Derived Brain Tumor Following Neural Stem Cell Transplantation in an Ataxia Telangiectasia Patient. Ninette Amariglio et al. Public Library of Science Medicine, Feb. 17, 2009. This makes it critical that further research is done into the safety of the procedure.

Stem cells

My daughter is 3 yrs old with CP. Whilst she has had no seziures we are very interested in having this treatment done while she is still young and healthy. As this is still in experemental stages it is very hard to find out were and how to go onto the next stage. We would do anything to experience this wounderfull new development. As I am a reg nurse and work with professionals on a daily basis I find it very frustrating when you have to fight and research new treatments for yourself, therefore very draining and slow. We just want to know were and how.

Caleb, donated stem cells and chemotherapy

I note your article on Shirley Turner from Dunedin and son Caleb and that they are going to Mexico and using donated stem cells.
How are the parents getting around this comment from reading about American Mary Schneider and her son, Ryan. PS I am interested in this answer for my own CP child.
http://www.cnsfoundation.org/site/News2?page=NewsArticle&id=7331
What do you say to other special-needs parents who want to know how they can try this same procedure for their children?
A At this point only children with cerebral palsy or similar brain injury, and who have their own cord blood banked at birth are candidates for this treatment.
In order to receive donated umbilical cord blood stem cells, a patient currently has to go through chemotherapy like that endured by cancer patients. Chemotherapy is likely to do significant harm to children, and so is not an option for children with stable neurological conditions like Ryan’s. So it has to be the patient’s own cord blood banked at birth, and not a sibling or other donated stem cells.
To date, seven more children have seen Dr. Kurtzberg. Their issues are all different (as a parent might imagine) and their results vary based upon their previous level of impairment and the viability of the stem cells used.

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Provincial AntiquesMiltonHomeware
Dunedin Sewing Machine Repairs DunedinSpecialist Trades
Graeme Sneddon BuildersDunedinBuilders
Kelsey Yaralla Kindergarten DunedinChildcare & Kindergartens