DVML head slams Butler's allegations

Guy Hedderwick
Guy Hedderwick
Allegations of inappropriate spending by a former manager at Forsyth Barr Stadium have prompted an angry retort from the company running the venue.

The claims came from former Stop the Stadium president Bev Butler in response to invoices and other documents released to her by Dunedin Venues Management Ltd, which runs the stadium.

The material showed DVML's former commercial manager, Guy Hedderwick, had accrued nearly $80,000 in travel costs and expenses while taking 51 work-related trips since 2010.

Mr Hedderwick, who last year opted to take a part-time role as a DVML contractor, based in Adelaide, was until then responsible for a team of staff tasked with attracting sponsors and events to the venue.

His travel included overseas trips for conferences and meetings in the United States, Singapore and Italy, meetings with potential sponsors across New Zealand, and talks in major Australian cities.

The spending details emerged just months after the Dunedin City Council launched a fundamental review of the stadium operation, following revelations DVML faced losses totalling $3.8 million over the next three years.

Ms Butler said it was ''simply staggering'' so many bills had been accrued with seemingly little to show for it, but DVML finance manager Neville Frost hit back in a strongly worded statement in which he defended the spending as legitimate and ''frugal'', while attacking Ms Butler's ''completely inaccurate and ill-informed'' claims.

''Ms Butler's personal and ill-informed attacks on members of our company are disgraceful and speak to her complete lack of personal integrity,'' he said in the statement.

Mr Frost said Mr Hedderwick's bills amounted to $20,000 a year, including flights, accommodation and expenses, which was appropriate for his role promoting the stadium internationally to try to secure events.

All travel was approved, expenses were ''well within'' a daily allowance, and ''all are legitimate travel expenses actually incurred''.

Mr Hedderwick's work had been ''integral'' to securing more than $3 million in sponsorship and a long list of events during the period, from major concerts to sporting clashes, the Nitro Circus, an international rodeo and equestrian events.

As a result, more than 800,000 people had so far attended events at the stadium, Mr Frost said.

''DVML does not have any concerns about the level of expenditure incurred by Mr Hedderwick,'' he said.

Mr Hedderwick, contacted in Australia this week, declined to comment.

Ms Butler said Mr Frost's comments were ''symptomatic of a man caught in a vice''.

''You'd expect him to go on the attack and say it's inaccurate - despite me quoting from their own invoices.''

She insisted Mr Hedderwick's spending - and that of other DVML managers - should form part of the stadium review announced by council chief executive Dr Sue Bidrose.

Dr Bidrose would not be drawn on that when asked, saying only the venue's management and governance would be scrutinised. DVML operational matters were an issue for Dunedin City Holdings Ltd, but she had discussed Ms Butler's claims with DCHL chairman Graham Crombie this week.

It was also raised during DCHL board's meeting on Tuesday, she said.

Mr Crombie said yesterday Mr Hedderwick's spending would not form part of the wider stadium review, which would focus on broader management, governance and structural issues.

Any concerns about specific spending - if there were any - would be a matter for new DVML chief executive Terry Davies, who was due to start work next week, Mr Crombie said.

A crude response?

What a crude response from DVML finance manager to Bev Butler's inquiries. To take over 20 hours to find a managers expense record says more about the DVML record-keeping then anything else. Are we privy to the specific breakdown of what 800,000 people attended by event. No way. 800,000 sounds grander. Like $50,000,000 private funding for stadium construction ? What $3,000,000 sponsorship? No specifics. No detail. No transparency. No honest communication. But change can only come from Directors and the City Council elected members, so keep up the pressure on those elected to represent ratepayers everybody. Write. Phone. Email. Text. Visit.

Thanks Bev

Where would society be without people like Bev? people who will ask the hard questions and insist that rate payer money is accounted for. She is now being accused of having no personal integrity by those who have shown scant regard for the losses rate payers of this city have incurred due to DVML's failure. Now they want to charge her for information she requests? How long does it take to look up a spreadsheet on the costs incurred by Mr Hedderwick during his tenure? I do hope Dr Bidrose sees what we all see, that those running DVML are secretive and arrogant when it comes to their lack of performance. Without people like Bev asking the hard questions DVML would be accountable to no-one, their attitude toward her is nothing short of disgusting.

DVML spendup

If people are getting upset with Bev Butler's statements, she must be getting too close to the truth for them to be comfortable.

Will the waste of ratepayer funds ever stop

It is fair to say we will never get accountiblity for this ongoing liablity that is the staduim.

Most of us are sick and disgusted at continually hearing about the utter waste of the cities finances this project has resulted in.

Why not let the ORFU and their supporters pay the bills.

What did he actually do?

So what exactly did Mr Hederwick do for DVML? initially he was in charge of the ill fated faux 'private fundraising', which originally was intended to be money diverted directly from the sale of luxury seating to help pay off that special short term loan taken out to cover the lack of actual fundraising - now days it seems that even that money is no longer going to DVL to pay off the loan (I can't see it on their balance sheets), instead it's staying with DVML to reduce their debts and help fund things like Mr Hederwick's trips to the US.

He couldn't actually have organised many concerts, most have been organised by outside promoters, except maybe for the recent Abba impersonators.

He must have done something for DVML to earn that large salary - perhaps once they finally explain where all our money keeps going to we'll find out.

[Abridged] 

DVML spendup

If Bev Butler's claims regarding the spending of DVML's Adelaide based "agent" are correct, DVML's Finance Manager's description of her "complete lack of personal integrity", is, in my opinion, quite simply defamation!

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Hair for HedzDunedinHairdressers
New Zealand Gift ShopDunedinGifts
Peter Murdoch TransportOamaruTransport & Haulage
Aotea Motor LodgeMiltonMotels