Establishing an independent ombudsman to deal with ACC
issues would help avoid privacy-related problems involving a
consent form that was used illegally, Dunedin claimant Dr
Denise Powell says.
A district court judge has upheld an appeal by Dr Powell, a
member of ACC lobby group Acclaim Otago, against being
required to sign the ACC form, called ACC 167.
Two just-released decisions from the district court say ACC
acted unlawfully when it told two clients they must sign a
consent form gathering private information or face having
their claims cut off.
One case involved Dr Powell, and the other a client with a
traumatic brain injury.
Judge Grant Powell heard both cases, upheld both appeals and
awarded costs against ACC.
Dr Powell said she and other claimants had unsuccessfully
tried to raise concerns with ACC about the excessively broad
consent form since 2009, including through two official ACC
liaison bodies, of which she has been a member.
After a major privacy breach by ACC the previous year, an
independent review team commissioned by the Privacy
Commissioner took issue with the form in 2012, and
''strongly'' encouraged ACC to consider ''detailed
consultation'' with people affected by any review.
Dr Powell said ombudsmen had already been appointed in
several other areas, including banking, and having a fully
independent ACC ombudsman would help deal with issues such as
the consent form.
An ombudsman would not be an alternative complaints service,
but would allow areas of genuine concern to be dealt with
ACC had been implementing a series of recommendations arising
from the privacy review report.
But the privacy of injured ACC claimants involved their
personal ''integrity'' and morale and many claimants believed
this issue should have been given a higher priority, she
Another ACC claimant, whose name was suppressed by the court,
and whose consent form-related appeal was also upheld by the
court this week, said the outcome meant ''a huge step forward
for all New Zealanders and not just for accident victims'',
by raising awareness of wider privacy issues.
ACC senior media adviser Glenn Donovan said that after the
recent court decision, which differed from previous court
decisions, changing the consent form was now an ''urgent
priority'' and ACC was working to make changes as soon as
ACC had already actioned 37 of the 44 core recommendations of
the independent privacy review.