Hospital deteriorates faster than expected

Joe Butterfield
Joe Butterfield
A building at Dunedin Hospital deteriorated more quickly than anyone expected, Southern District Health Board chairman Joe Butterfield says.

Under pressure last week because of national media coverage about leaks in the surgical theatre suite, Health Minister Tony Ryall confirmed last Wednesday night the Cabinet was expected to consider a business case for the project next year.

Mr Butterfield said the leaks affecting the surgical theatre suite would be fixed, and the job was unaffected by the wait for confirmation of the rebuilding.

''The problem is that the building is old, and is starting to deteriorate more quickly I think than probably we had hoped or expected.''

Asked if the board had been scrimping on maintenance to reduce its deficit, Mr Butterfield indicated the issue was not relevant, because of the scale of the work required.

''People think that, and there's some truth in it, but on the other hand: what is repairs and maintenance? ''The repairs and maintenance that would be needed to fix that building is probably as much as it would cost to build a new one.''

Board management said it expected a builders' report by the end of this week about the leaks. Parts of the suite were drenched in heavy rain last month, desterilising some equipment and disrupting some services.

Management also clarified a report of a lift ''free falling'' five flights in Dunedin Hospital. Finance director Peter Beirne said the lift, which carried a passenger, had failed to stop at designated floors, the reason for which was unclear.

It was not a free fall. Information released under the Official Information Act to the Labour Party disclosed the incident, which was described as a free fall in the document.

Chief executive Carole Heatly said management hoped health board members could approve a business case in February.

The process was complex, because it involved a detailed assessment of future health needs before signing off the project. The cost of the project has not been determined.

Officials from Treasury and the National Health Board would visit Dunedin today to discuss the project.

Mr Beirne said he was pleased with the situation.

''I couldn't be happier about where we are at the moment ... it's a really positive process to be in for Southern at the moment.''

Association of Salaried Medical Specialists executive director Ian Powell said in a statement Dunedin Hospital had been allowed to become run down.

''Rebuilding the hospital is well overdue, and we'd like to see a real commitment to this project from the Government.

''Patients deserve better facilities and so do the senior doctors and other staff working at the hospital, so we're urging the Government to make a decision as soon as possible.''

New Zealand Nurses Organisation organiser Lorraine Lobb said she was pleased the rebuild was a step closer, but an immediate fix was needed for the leaking surgical theatre.



New Dunedin hospital

Yes good design is essential. Actually Timaru Hospital was re-vamped/designed just a few years ago and is a huge improvement for patients and staff and families, all of whom should be consulted when an upgrade is considered in Dunedin.

I've worked in hospitals built in the 1800's to those built in the 1980's and good design makes a huge difference to treatment.

Dunedin hospital is a disgrace and should get urgent attention- not just be 'considered' next year. 

Design of new hospital

It would be a very good thing indeed to have a rebuild of Dunedin hospital. Not only are new hospitals safer and cleaner but they can truly save lives when well thought out and designed. For instance, as a doctor I always thought the design of the Timaru Hospital was very good as it allowed for the minimum of distance (and hence, time) between facilities. A tall building with a smaller footprint allows ease of transfer of patients and equipment between floors without having to walk or roll beds over longer horizontal distances and delay treatment. For example, if a patient becomes critically ill in any ward and needs to be transfered to theatre via imaging then the patient only has to be wheeled to an elevator to take them straight up or down. Likewise, doctors don't have to walk as far to reach a patient in need of assistance. It is much more pleasurable and rewarding to work in a space which you know is offering the maximum care to the patient. When architects are working on a new plan it would be wise to consult all those who work in the hospital environment as to their opinion on the way to meet the needs of the people of Dunedin.



Planned obsolecence

In this case, structural deterioration was identified but expected to take longer.

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Orderings Nurseries (Dn) LimitedDunedinGardening
Kings Corner DairyDunedinDairies
Smiths Sports ShoesDunedinFootwear
Greenbox Containers LtdDunedinContainer Sales & Lease