$95,000 plan to keep watch on St Clair sea wall

Peter Standring
Peter Standring
A closer watch needs to be kept on the St Clair sea wall until Dunedin city councillors decide what long-term fix - if any - is needed, a report suggests.

The report, by council maintenance engineer Peter Standring, will be considered by councillors, who are set to begin deliberating on the draft budget for 2014-15 from today.

Mr Standring's report suggested the council should allocate $95,000 to pay for an interim risk management plan for the battered St Clair sea wall.

The plan would allow council staff to keep a closer eye on the wall, looking for further signs of deterioration, until longer-term options could be considered at next year's long-term plan budget discussions.

The risk management plan would include weekly visual inspections, fortnightly sand level surveys and six-monthly surveys checking for signs the sea wall could be settling or moving, Mr Standring's report said.

As well, the sea wall's panels would be inspected for signs of deterioration every year, and rocks at the foot of the wall would be checked and rearranged every six months, he said.

The council would also be ready to react to any signs of problems arising from the inspections, and would draw up an emergency contingency plan should a partial failure of the sea wall or rock revetment occur, he said.

The interim approach would cost the council at least $95,000, but could rise by up to $160,000, to $255,000, if all identified risks became a reality, Mr Standring warned.

That included the anticipated $100,000 cost to the council if the emergency contingency plan needed to be put into action, he said.

The recommendation came after a series of severe storms in May last year stripped sand from the beach, resulting in the appearance of sinkholes along the Esplanade at St Clair.

The council has since spent $680,000 on emergency remedial work and reinstating temporary access to the beach, while commissioning Opus International Consultants to study possible long-term solutions to the problem.

Mr Standring said the council was only at stage one of a four-stage approach to rectifying problems at St Clair, but Opus had identified ''conceptual options'' to be considered in more detail.

Those options ranged from continuing the existing approach of reactive repairs and maintenance, to changing the existing sea wall to building an offshore groyne to help protect the beach and sea wall.

Each option had a range of adverse effects, and would require a resource consent, and should be considered in more detail as part of next year's long-term plan hearings, he suggested.

A report on the need for further studies into long-term options for the sea wall was expected to be ready for councillors to consider in two to four months, he said.

In the meantime, he recommended councillors agree to the interim risk management plan, with the $95,000 cost to be paid for by drawing on $130,000 in unspent transportation operational funding from 2013-14.

The additional costs of up to $160,000, if risks became a reality, could be covered by delaying some footpath renewal work, even though that approach was not sustainable and ''should be avoided if possible'', he noted.


Sea wall watching in the Old Country

Really, only the Dutch know about these things. Get an Old Zeelander.

How much?

No mention from Mr Standring as to how much his report has already cost us.

This situation is just like the stadium mess and a reminder of what happens when those running the city just don't listen.

Back in the forties, the Americans spoke of, and were going to attend to, blowing it through from the harbour to the beach. History shows us that the DCC didn't listen 70 years ago and it seems that nothing has changed. What is the use of hindsight when it's ignored?

Just for the record, the ocean is bigger than all of us and it will go wherever it feels like. No amount of rocks and concrete, let alone spending another $100,000 for anyone, including QSRC, to keep an eye on it will stop it. 

The best thing council could do is to not allow any more building in South Dunedin and for everyone to move to higher ground over time. How much will that cost?  Mmm... nothing. 

From where I sit

Just create the angle which reduces the vacuum effect that sucks out the fill under and behind the wall. So, the council are receiving loot galore from rates. Good on you, pay rises all round. Wall watching? Whats next on the list? Bring back Mork and Mindy ..E.T had it sussed. [Abridged]


I'll do it for $85k. I live near by. I'll also require a company vehicle and credit card for lunches at the Esplanade or Neptuno. 

I could do that

$95,000 to watch a wall - sounds like a good job.

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Living Space DunedinDunedinApartments
Skyline QueenstownQueenstownRecreational Activities
Bags of BarginsDunedinGifts
Bob Wyber Contemporary JewelleryDunedinJewellers