The Green Island landfill was the subject of debate at
yesterday's DCC Annual Plan hearing. Photo from ODT files.
The Dunedin City Council wants more information before
making a decision on increasing charges and installing a
$110,000 weighbridge at the Green Island landfill.
The move came after last-minute uncertainty over the costs
and implications of options for the landfill at yesterday's
2014-15 annual plan deliberations.
Councillors had, earlier this year, voted to consult the
public on adding a second weighbridge at the Green Island
landfill, following an outcry over the end of discretionary
charges earlier this year.
The proposal, together with landfill charges for the coming
financial year, were subsequently released for public
However, council staff had since discovered charges needed to
rise by more than indicated to avoid a $467,000 shortfall.
That was confirmed after staff asked all vehicles to use the
landfill's existing weighbridge - normally reserved for
commercial users - as part of a three-day trial testing the
impact of a second weighbridge.
The extra data confirmed 63% of all landfill customers would
be better off if a second weighbridge was added, but also
revealed the expected shortfall, council solid waste manager
Ian Featherston said.
That meant the per tonne charges would need to rise for
general waste, from the $130 a tonne figure consulted on, to
$145 a tonne; for green waste, from $80 a tonne to $100 a
tonne; and for mixed loads, from $110 a tonne to $115 a
tonne, his report said.
Councillors were being asked to approve the increased charges
yesterday and decide whether to proceed with a weighbridge or
However, Cr Kate Wilson said the prospect of approving fee
increases the public had not been consulted on caused her
''Process-wise ... it's fraught.
''I'm not sure we're actually in a position to make a
decision today, because it lacks robustness,'' she said.
Dunedin Mayor Dave Cull agreed, saying more information on
the costs and implications of each option, including their
effect on any council shortfall or surplus, was needed.
That was despite council group chief financial officer Grant
McKenzie revising the estimated shortfall down yesterday, to
about $380,000, ''all other things being equal''.
Mr Featherston, responding to questions, said the city's
landfill fees ''tended to be at the bottom end of the
market'', compared with other centres, when last studied
about 18 months ago.
He also doubted higher fees would encourage illegal dumping,
saying those paying less would be those typically arriving
with smaller loads.
However, Cr Wilson questioned whether lifting charges could
encourage more people to use the Fairfield landfill run by
the council's commercial competitor, Waste Management.
Mr Avery said the council would take a hit if higher charges
encouraged customers to the council's commercial competitor
However, in the past, the council's competitor had responded
similarly when the council raised its charges, he said.