Independent auditors have given a former Forsyth Barr
Stadium manager the all clear following claims of inappropriate
spending, but the company running the venue has not escaped
The findings came in a report by independent auditors Crowe
Horwath, commissioned by the Dunedin City Council, which
reviewed spending by former DVML commercial manager Guy
That followed the release of documents to former Stop the
Stadium president Bev Butler in March, showing Mr Hedderwick
had accrued nearly $80,000 in travel costs and expenses while
taking 51 work-related trips since 2010.
The information prompted a public spat between Ms Butler, who
labelled the spending ''simply staggering'', and DVML finance
manager Neville Frost, who defended the spending as
legitimate and ''frugal''.
The Crowe Horwath report, released to the Otago Daily
Times on Friday, highlighted instances where Mr
Hedderwick had breached DVML spending guidelines using his
company credit card.
However, it concluded there were ''no significant concerns''
relating to Mr Hedderwick's expenses and instead criticised
DVML for failing to apply its own policies and procedures in
DVML chief executive Terry Davies said when contacted he
accepted the findings, and the company was working with
council staff to review and tighten its processes.
''We're taking that up with all of our team, to re-educate
[staff] right through all of our policies and procedures.''
He confirmed Mr Hedderwick's part-time role as a DVML
contractor based in Adelaide had ''come to an end'' last
However, the change reflected the appointment of Mr Davies,
who had a background in content acquisition, and was not
related to the review's findings, he said.
Mr Hedderwick, contacted in Australia, said he had not seen
the final report but was pleased it gave his spending ''a
clean bill of health''.
He defended DVML staff, saying they put in long hours ''with
no thanks and very little acknowledgement for their
''There is very little gratitude for the impossible task they
are asked to do.''
The Crowe Horwath report, spanning 14 pages, detailed
$144,879 in spending by Mr Hedderwick over four years,
beginning in March 2010.
That included $108,263 in travel and entertainment expenses,
higher than the original figure released to Ms Butler in
The report identified 118 transactions, together worth
$3974.50, which were approved by DVML without the required
invoices from Mr Hedderwick.
That was in breach of DVML policies, as were anther 71
transactions for flights and accommodation, worth $28,852.03,
made without evidence of sign-off by DVML afterwards.
Mr Hedderwick had also accrued $1163.33 in work-related
expenses on his DVML credit card while working as a
contractor in Australia, despite company policy requiring
cards to be handed back at the end of full-time employment.
The expenses were without supporting documentation, although
credit card statements suggested no ''suspicious activity'',
the report found.
The report also found only four instances where Mr
Hedderwick's accommodation costs - while on trips to the
United States, Singapore, Italy and Australia - exceeded $300
His daily spend on ''subsistence expenses'' - including meals
and alcoholic drinks - averaged $59 per day, below the
company's $75 daily limit.
Ms Butler said when contacted it was ''clear'' Mr Hedderwick
''did not comply with good business practice'', while
spending sums released by Mr Frost following an official
information request were understated.
''It is unacceptable for tens of thousands of dollars of
public money not to be fully accounted for. Guy Hedderwick,
Neville Frost and the [DVML] board all failed the ratepayers
and should be held to account for their failures.''
Mr Davies said there was ''always going to be some things''
when spending was under such scrutiny.
However, he had been assured by Crowe Horwath there was
nothing untoward in Mr Hedderwick's spending, and DVML's
mistakes would be rectified.
''We acknowledge that that's a problem and we've got to get